Article Types
Conceptual Foundations in Language Research (CFLR) welcomes submissions that offer substantial review papers, conceptual, theoretical, or synthesis-based contributions to language research and applied linguistics.
To facilitate diverse theoretical dialogues, the journal accepts the following manuscript types:
1. A State-of-the art Review/Research Agenda
- Purpose: A state-of-the-art (SotA) review/ A Research Agenda is a form of narrative literature review that summarizes, synthesizes, and analyzes the most current and up-to-date research and developments within a specific field or topic.
- Word Count: Up to 10,000 words (inclusive of abstract, text, references, tables, and figures).
- Structure:
Title & Abstract: Structured or unstructured abstract (150–250 words) highlighting the scope and main takeaways of the review.
Introduction: Defines the topic, establishes its significance, and outlines the boundaries and objectives of the review.
Thematic Synthesis & Analysis: Organizes recent scholarship thematically or chronologically, critically evaluating key debates, methodological trends, and breakthroughs.
Future Directions & Conclusion: Identifies unresolved gaps in the literature and proposes concrete avenues for future research and practice.
2. Research Synthesis, Systematic Reviews & Meta-Analyses
-
Purpose: Research syntheses can be on any topic (methodological and substantive) in language research. Comprehensive syntheses of existing literature (e.g., systematic reviews, scoping reviews, or quantitative meta-analyses) that address critical research questions and map out subfields.
-
Word Count: Up to 8,000 words (inclusive of abstract, references, tables, and figures).
-
Structure: Abstract (up to 200 words), Introduction, Methods (search strategy, selection criteria, PRISMA standards), Results & Synthesis, Implications, and Conclusion.
3. Methodological Article
- Purpose: Methodological articles focus on a methodological issue or method related to conducting research syntheses or for understanding conceptual foundations in language research. The paper can either be descriptive (e.g., introducing an innovative method for conducting literature search such as an AI tool) or discursive (e.g., discussing challenges of using an AI tool or other tools in conducting research syntheses). Regardless, the paper needs to be accompanied with examples, preferably in Applied Linguistics or a cognate field, to illustrate the information presented.
-
Word Count: Up to 5,000 words (inclusive of references).
-
Structure: Abstract (up to 200 words), Introduction, Method & Description, Examples, Discussion, and Implications.
4. Position, Conceptual & Theoretical Papers
-
Purpose: Original articles proposing theoretical models, conceptual frameworks, taxonomies, or epistemological approaches for language teachers and students. These papers critique, refine, or re-conceptualize existing theories without requiring primary empirical data.
-
Word Count: Up to 4,000 words (inclusive of abstract, text, references, tables, and figures).
-
Structure:
-
Abstract: Up to 200 words.
-
Keywords: 3 to 5 keywords.
-
Main Body: Introduction (theoretical gap/problem), Conceptual Framework/Synthesis (themed subsections), and Theoretical & Practical Implications.
-
Conclusion: Summary of the primary conceptual contribution and future directions.
-
5. New Theories and Models
-
Purpose: Original articles dedicated to introducing novel theoretical constructs, explanatory models, or formal frameworks in language research and applied linguistics. Unlike papers that primarily critique or synthesize existing paradigms, these submissions focus on building and articulating new theoretical architectures, specifying their core components, mechanisms, and testable propositions.
-
Word Count: Up to 5,000 words (inclusive of abstract, text, references, tables, and figures).
-
Structure:
-
Abstract: Up to 200 words.
-
Keywords: 3 to 5 keywords.
-
Main Body: Introduction (rationale and theoretical gap), Model/Theory Specification (core constructs, mechanisms, and visual representations), and Comparison with Existing Frameworks.
-
Implications & Conclusion: Empirical testability, pedagogical or practical applications, and future research directions.
-
6. Critical Essays & Perspectives
-
Purpose: Short, thought-provoking commentaries and epistemological debates that challenge current practices, paradigms, or trends in language research.
-
Word Count: Up to 3,000 words (inclusive of references).
-
Structure: Abstract (up to 150 words), Introduction, Argumentative Sections, and Call to Action/Conclusion
7. Forums and Debates
Purpose: Curated multi-author exchanges, point-counterpoint dialogues, and structured academic debates addressing contentious theoretical, conceptual, or epistemological issues in language research. Typically anchored by a lead target article followed by invited or open peer commentaries and an author rejoinder.
Word Count: 1,500 to 3,000 words per contribution (inclusive of abstract and references).
Structure:
Abstract: Up to 150 words.
Keywords: 3 to 5 keywords.
Main Body: Context/Position Statement (framing the core debate), Critical Engagement/Counter-arguments (themed subsections), and Synthesis/Path Forward.
References: Concise list of key cited works.