International Journal of Language Learning and
Teaching Research
IJLLTR
Volume 1 (2026)
https://doi.org/10.65553/IJLLTR.260104
Navigating a World of
Informal Digital Language Learning: A Research Agenda
Chaohai Xue Guangxiang Leon Liu
School of Foreign
Languages, Southeast University, Nanjing, China
Corresponding author: g.liu@seu.edu.cn
Abstract
Rapid advances in digital
technologies have reshaped how additional languages are learned beyond the
classroom, bringing informal digital language learning (IDLL) to increasing
prominence in second language (L2) education. Despite its growing importance,
IDLL research remains constrained by several persistent limitations, including
an English-centric evidence base, limited methodological diversity, and a
concentration of research in well-resourced contexts. To address these
limitations and advance the field, this paper proposes a research agenda
organized around seven key directions, grounded in a six-dimensional
conceptualization of language learning beyond the classroom: location,
formality, pedagogy, locus of control, trajectory, and digital mediation. Drawing
on a comprehensive review of existing research, we identify underexplored areas
of IDLL and outline priorities for future inquiry. In doing so, we seek to
broaden the conceptual, methodological, linguistic, and contextual scope of
IDLL research and provide directions for its continued development in language
education.
Keywords:
Informal
digital language learning; research agenda; computer assisted language learning;
language learning beyond the classroom
Global digital transformation has fundamentally reshaped the ways in which languages are learned. Over the past several decades, successive technological shifts, from wired devices in the 1990s and 2000s, to mobile and social media platforms in the 2010s, and more recently to generative artificial intelligence (AI) tools, have progressively extended language learning beyond textbook-centered classrooms and created new opportunities for second language (L2) learning and use (Lee, 2026; Liu & Zhao, 2026a; Soyoof et al., 2023). With digital technologies now embedded in learners’ everyday lives, language learning beyond the classroom increasingly draws on a wealth of online resources, including internet memes, music, and short videos, with growing evidence linking such activities to a range of linguistic and non-linguistic outcomes (cf. Lee & Chiu, 2023; Lee & Dressman, 2018; Rezai et al., 2024; Ushioda & Dörnyei, 2017; Zadorozhnyy & Lee, 2025). This growing body of evidence has contributed to the emergence of informal digital language learning (IDLL) as an important area of inquiry within computer-assisted language learning (CALL). IDLL broadly concerns L2 learners’ self-directed and autonomous language learning through digital devices and online platforms beyond formal educational settings (Liu & Soyoof, 2026).
As research on language learning
beyond the classroom has expanded, researchers have proposed a range of
partially overlapping terms to describe such learning practices (see Figure 1).
While these terms generally converge on language learning beyond formal
educational settings, they differ considerably in conceptual scope. As Figure 1
illustrates, these differences can be understood along four dimensions: whether
a definition encompasses non-formal activities (vs. only informal ones),
teacher-initiated practices (vs. only learner-initiated ones), “real-world”
contexts (vs. only digital environments), and languages other than English (vs.
only English). Together, these dimensions produce a continuum of conceptual
scope, ranging from broad formulations such as language learning (and teaching)
beyond the classroom (Reinders et al., 2022) to more narrowly defined concepts such as online
informal learning of English (Sockett, 2011).
Among these terms, informal
digital learning of English (IDLE), first conceptualized by Lee and Dressman (2018) and further
elaborated by Lee (2022a), has
received particularly strong scholarly attention (Liu
& Soyoof, 2026). IDLE focuses on
learners’ self-directed use of digital technologies to learn and use English
beyond formal educational settings (Liu, 2024; Liu & Hossain, 2026). With English occupying a prominent position as a
global lingua franca (Jenkins, 2006,
2013), IDLE has become the most
extensively researched area within the broader field of IDLL (Liu
& Soyoof, 2026).
Figure 1. Terms about Language Learning
Outside Formal Educational Settings (Arndt & Kusyk, 2026, p. 2)
The growing body of IDLE
scholarship has contributed to the broader development of IDLL at conceptual,
theoretical, and empirical levels. Conceptually, prior research has worked to
delineate IDLL from related constructs and clarify its scope (Lee, 2026; Liu
& Soyoof, 2026; Sundqvist
& Sylvén, 2016). Theoretically,
established theories and frameworks have been extended to explain learners’ informal
digital practices. For instance, Guo and Lee (2023) drew on Bronfenbrenner’s (1979) ecological systems theory to
examine factors shaping learners’ IDLE participation, while Liu and Ma (2024) applied Davis’s (1989) technology acceptance model to explain EFL learners’
adoption of ChatGPT for IDLE. Alongside these applications of established
theories, new frameworks, including Lee’s (2022a, 2025) IDLE
continuum model and care – innovation –sustainability model, have been
developed to conceptualize and inform IDLL practices across educational
contexts. Empirically, a growing body of evidence derived from surveys,
interviews, and experimental studies has documented diverse linguistic and non-linguistic
outcomes associated with IDLL (see Figure 2).
Despite these advances, IDLL
research remains uneven in its linguistic and geographical coverage. Most
studies continue to focus on English learning in digital environments, leaving
languages other than English (LOTEs) and learning in non-digital, real-world
contexts comparatively underexplored (Guo & Lee, 2023; Lee, 2026). In
a review of 206 publications on informal language learning published between
2000 and 2020, Kusyk et al. (2025) found that English was the target language in 66.4% of
the publications, compared with only 7.0% for French and 6.6% for Japanese.
Such an Anglocentric evidence base limits our understanding of how informal
language learning may differ across languages with distinct linguistic,
sociocultural, and digital contexts. A similar imbalance is evident in the
geographical distribution of IDLL research. Many empirical studies have been
conducted in relatively well-resourced contexts, including Sweden (e.g., Lee
& Sylvén, 2021), South Korea (e.g., Lee,
2019), and Austria (e.g., Trinder,
2017), whereas learners in
less-resourced countries and regions remain comparatively underrepresented.
Figure 2. Benefits of IDLL (Lee, 2026)
Against this backdrop, this paper
develops a research agenda for broadening and advancing IDLL scholarship.
Rather than simply cataloguing existing gaps, we identify key areas in which
further conceptual, methodological, linguistic, and contextual work is needed
and outline directions for future research. The following section first
establishes the conceptual basis for understanding IDLL, before turning to
seven research directions intended to address persistent limitations in the
field and extend its scope.
IDLL builds on more than a decade of research into
technology-supported learning in Teaching English to Speakers of Other
Languages (TESOL) and second language acquisition (SLA). As this area has
expanded, however, it has developed alongside a proliferation of related and
partially overlapping concepts, including extramural English (Sundqvist, 2009),
out-of-class language learning with technology (Lai & Gu, 2011), and computer-assisted language learning in the digital
wilds (Sauro & Zourou, 2019), with no single term encompassing the full range of practices
examined in the field (Kusyk et al., 2025).
The resulting conceptual overlap can blur important distinctions among
different forms of learning beyond the classroom. For example, equating IDLL
with extramural English overlooks distinctions between semi-structured
extracurricular practices and less structured extramural practices (Zhang
& Liu, 2024). Conceptual ambiguity
is compounded by limited theoretical grounding in parts of the literature.
Kusyk et al. (2025) reported that
33% of the IDLL studies they reviewed did not specify a conceptual or
theoretical framework, a proportion that reached 37% in Soyoof et al.’s (2023) review. A clearer conceptual basis is therefore needed
to organize the diverse practices encompassed by IDLL and guide future
research. For this purpose, we draw on Liu’s (2025b) six-dimensional conceptualization of language learning
beyond the classroom as the organizing framework for the research agenda
developed in this paper.
Language learning beyond the
classroom has historically received less scholarly attention than
classroom-based language learning (Benson, 2011). To conceptualize this broad domain and establish a
basis for systematic analysis, Benson (2011) proposed an analytical framework comprising four
dimensions: location, formality, pedagogy, and locus of control. Benson’s (2011) four original dimensions capture complementary aspects
of learning beyond the classroom. Location specifies where learning occurs,
extending from homes and community spaces to online environments outside the
conventional classroom. Formality concerns how far learning is organized within
institutional structures and tied to predetermined curricula or assessment.
IDLL typically occupies the less formal end of this continuum, although its
boundaries with more structured learning practices may remain fluid. Pedagogy,
by contrast, concerns the extent and nature of instruction. Benson (2011) conceptualized this dimension as a continuum ranging
from self-instruction, where learners intentionally use materials designed for
language learning, to naturalistic learning, where language development may
arise incidentally through activities not primarily undertaken for learning.
Finally, locus of control concerns who makes decisions about the learning
process. Compared with formal instruction, IDLL generally gives learners
greater control over what, when, where, and how they learn. These four dimensions
thus capture the spatial, organizational, instructional, and agentive
characteristics of learning beyond the classroom, but they offer a less
explicit account of how such learning develops over time and is shaped by
digital technologies.
To address these aspects, Liu (2025b) added trajectory and
digital mediation (see Figure 3). Trajectory introduces a temporal perspective,
drawing attention to how learners’ informal practices develop, shift, and
sometimes discontinue over time rather than assuming a stable pattern of
participation. Digital mediation, meanwhile, captures the constitutive role of
technology in shaping what learners can do and how they interact. From this
perspective, digital technologies are not simply channels through which
existing learning practices are transferred outside the classroom; their
affordances can reshape learners’ access to linguistic resources, forms of
interaction, and opportunities for participation. The two additional dimensions
therefore extend Benson’s framework from describing the conditions under which
learning beyond the classroom occurs to examining how such learning evolves
within changing digital environments.
Figure 3. The Conceptual Basis of IDLE (Liu, 2025b)
Together, these six dimensions provide a conceptual lens
for examining the multiple forms that IDLL can take, reflecting “the fluid
boundaries between formal and informal, individual and networked learning in a
rapidly changing digital world”
(Liu & Lee, 2026, p. 6). Importantly, the framework also provides the
conceptual bridge between the current literature and the research agenda
developed below. By considering where IDLL occurs, how it is organized and
directed, how it changes over time, and how technologies shape these processes,
the six dimensions help identify areas that have received disproportionate
attention as well as those that remain insufficiently examined. The next
section builds on this framework to develop seven directions for future IDLL
research.
A growing body of research has established
IDLL as an important mode of language learning, but understanding what learners
actually do in informal digital environments requires
methods suited to the conditions under which such learning occurs (Khanh-Quynh & Ngo, 2026; Lee, 2026).
Unlike classroom learning, IDLL often unfolds across multiple digital spaces,
at irregular intervals, and with limited researcher or teacher oversight.
Learners may move between platforms, activities, and purposes, while their
practices change over time and remain closely tied to their everyday lives (Lee,
2022, 2026). These characteristics pose a methodological challenge:
approaches that capture learners’ perceptions at a single point in time may
reveal important patterns, but they provide only a partial account of how IDLL
is actually practiced and develops. Methodological
diversity is therefore particularly important for building an evidence base
that reflects the dynamic and context-dependent nature of IDLL (Reinders
& Benson, 2017).
Existing research, however, has
relied heavily on a relatively limited set of designs and data sources. In a
scoping review of 30 IDLL studies, Soyoof et al. (2023) found that 36.7% adopted qualitative designs and 26.7% mixed-methods designs, while questionnaires (46.6%) and
interviews (36.6%) were the most frequently used instruments; only two of the
nine qualitative studies were longitudinal. Kusyk et al. (2025) similarly reported that 80% of the studies they
reviewed were cross-sectional, with questionnaires (35%) and interviews (23%)
dominating data collection. Reviewing 103 studies, Guo and Lee (2023) likewise identified questionnaires, interviews, and
observations as the most commonly used instruments.
This pattern is also evident in Lee’s (2022b) review of 76 studies, which showed that methods capable
of capturing learning as it occurs, including language logs, computer tracking,
stimulated recall, and personal learning histories, were used much less
frequently. Taken together, these reviews point not simply to a lack of
methodological variety, but to a mismatch between the dynamic character of IDLL
and the predominantly retrospective and cross-sectional methods used to
investigate it.
This mismatch has several
consequences for what the field can claim about IDLL. First, heavy reliance on
self-reported data makes it difficult to determine how closely reported
practices correspond to learners’ actual digital behavior, as participants may
inaccurately recall or report the frequency and nature of their IDLL activities
(Guo & Lee, 2023;
Lee, 2026). Second,
cross-sectional designs provide limited insight into how learners begin,
maintain, modify, or discontinue informal digital practices over time, and they
cannot readily establish the direction of relationships between IDLL and
learning outcomes (Kusyk et al., 2025;
Soyoof et al., 2023). Relatedly,
the widespread use of correlational analyses, including structural equation
modeling, has been valuable for identifying relationships among IDLL, learner
characteristics, and outcomes, but cannot by itself establish causal effects (Kusyk
et al., 2025; Lee, 2026). Third, methods centered primarily on individual
learners can overlook the social and ecological conditions within which their
practices develop, including family resources, peer networks, educational
institutions, and broader technological environments (Guo & Lee, 2023). The methodological challenge facing IDLL is therefore
not simply that the field needs more methods. It needs methods that correspond
more closely to the temporal, behavioral, and ecological characteristics of the
phenomenon being studied.
Despite its inclusive label, IDLL remains strongly
Anglocentric in its empirical and theoretical development. Languages other than
English (LOTEs) continue to be substantially underrepresented as target
languages (Liu, Zhao, et al., 2024; Sundqvist & Sylvén, 2016). This imbalance is not surprising
given the historically privileged position of English in international
communication, education, technology, and digital media. The global prominence
of English has been shaped by colonial histories as well as contemporary
economic and institutional structures, processes examined critically through
concepts such as linguistic imperialism (Phillipson, 2008). Consequently, English is often positioned as a necessary linguistic
resource, whereas LOTEs may be perceived as optional additions to learners’
linguistic repertoires (Lu & Shen, 2022; Takahashi & Harumi, 2026; Ushioda & Dörnyei, 2017). These broader conditions have also
shaped the knowledge base of IDLL. Much of what is currently known about IDLL,
including its conceptual models, measurement instruments, and relationships
with learner variables such as willingness to communicate, enjoyment, and
self-efficacy, has been developed primarily through research on English (Dressman & Sadler, 2020; Guo & Lee, 2023; Kusyk et al., 2025; Liu, Zhang, et al., 2024; Soyoof et al., 2023).
Decentering
English, however, requires more than simply replicating IDLE studies with
another target language. LOTEs themselves constitute an extremely heterogeneous
category. They differ in global and regional status, linguistic distance from
learners’ existing languages, writing systems, learner populations, and the
availability of digital resources and communities. Research on LOTE motivation
has likewise concentrated disproportionately on a relatively small group of
widely taught, high-prestige languages, particularly European languages taught
across Europe, North America, and East Asia (Mendoza & Phung, 2019). Treating all
LOTEs as a single alternative to English therefore risks reproducing another
form of simplification: evidence derived from French, German, or Spanish cannot
automatically represent the experiences of learners of Malay, Khmer, Swahili,
or other languages with different linguistic and sociocultural conditions.
One
important source of such variation is linguistic distance. Chiswick and Miller’s
(2005) scalar measure,
for example, places Norwegian and Swedish among the languages closest to
English, followed by French, German, and Spanish, whereas Vietnamese, Mandarin,
Japanese, and Korean are considerably more distant. Such differences may shape
informal learning in ways that English-centered models do not fully capture.
Learners encountering unfamiliar writing systems, phonological distinctions,
morphological structures, or limited lexical overlap may need different
resources and develop different patterns of practice outside the classroom.
Importantly, however, linguistic distance should not be treated as determining
learners’ experiences; its effects interact with motivation, prior linguistic
knowledge, access to resources, and the social meanings attached to particular languages. Huang’s (2019) study of university students in Taiwan learning
eight LOTEs across Southeast Asian, Northeast Asian, and European language
groups, for instance, showed that intended effort was associated primarily with
learning experience, ideal self, and interest in the target-language culture or
community. Woore et al. (2026) similarly found
differences in the motivational structure of secondary-school learners studying
European languages and Chinese in England: perceived language aptitude emerged
as a separate motivational component for learners of European languages, whereas
learners of Chinese placed greater emphasis on novelty, challenge, and its
character-based writing system. These findings suggest that constructs
established in English-learning research may remain relevant across languages,
but their salience, configuration, and interpretation can vary with the target
language and learning context.
The
online availability of the target language introduce
another important source of variation. Languages differ considerably in the
quantity and diversity of online content available to learners, the size and
accessibility of digital communities, and their representation in emerging
technologies. For widely used languages with large digital ecosystems, learners
may readily encounter streaming media, social networking content, online
communities, and AI-supported resources. For languages with smaller digital
footprints, informal learning may depend on a much narrower range of resources
and interlocutors. Liu and Zhao (2026b), for example,
note that learners of Malay may encounter constraints related to the
availability of subtitled media, online communities, and specialized digital
learning resources. The opportunities for IDLL are therefore partly structured
by the digital ecology of the target language itself. This raises questions
that are largely invisible when research focuses predominantly on English: How
do learners pursue informal digital learning when target-language resources are
scarce? Which platforms and communities become particularly important? And how
do learners compensate when mainstream digital and AI tools provide uneven
support across languages?
Emerging
research on LOTEs already indicates the value of asking such questions.
Informal digital learning of Chinese (IDLC), in particular,
has developed into a growing strand of IDLL research. Zhao, Liu, et al.
(2026), studying 519
multilingual learners of Chinese in Thailand, found that shyness was indirectly
associated with classroom participation through enjoyment and boredom, while
the two emotions were linked to different aspects of the Chinese learning
experience. Other work has begun to identify heterogeneity within IDLC itself.
A latent profile analysis of 516 adolescent learners of Chinese in New Zealand
showed that the relationship between digital competence and IDLC participation
differed according to learners’ boredom profiles (Zhao, Wang, et al., 2026). Research is also
beginning to extend to less commonly taught languages. Liu and Zhao’s (2026b) mixed-methods
study of Chinese students learning Malay as a third language, for example,
identified motivation and self-efficacy as important predictors of their
informal digital learning. Although this evidence remains too limited to
support broad cross-linguistic conclusions, it demonstrates why English-derived
assumptions need to be examined rather than simply transferred to other target
languages.
Future
research should therefore pursue multilingual expansion in a way that treats
target language as theoretically consequential rather than merely as a change
of research setting. The empirical base needs to extend beyond both
English and the relatively small group of high-prestige LOTEs that currently
receive most attention, with greater attention to less commonly taught
languages such as Malay and Khmer and to languages with comparatively limited
digital resources (Liu,
Zhao, et al., 2024; Liu & Zhao, 2026b). Also, constructs and instruments developed in
IDLE should be tested for conceptual and measurement equivalence before being
applied across languages. Rather than assuming that
constructs such as enjoyment, self-efficacy, willingness to communicate, or
digital competence function identically, comparative studies can examine which
relationships remain stable and which become language- or context-specific (Dörnyei & Al-Hoorie, 2017). Multi-language
and same-learner designs would be especially informative because they can help
distinguish differences associated with the target language from differences
attributable to learner background or educational context.
Decentering
English thus means more than increasing the number of LOTE studies. It requires
using linguistic diversity to reconsider what IDLL is, how it is practiced, and
whether its established explanations travel across languages. Comparative
research across languages with different linguistic features, social positions,
and digital resources can reveal which aspects of current IDLL knowledge are
broadly applicable and which are products of the particular
conditions surrounding English. In this sense, LOTEs should not occupy
the margins of IDLL research. They provide an important basis for testing and
extending the field’s theoretical claims.
IDLL research remains geographically concentrated
in relatively well-resourced and technologically connected settings (Liu & Hossain, 2026), including South Korea (Lee, 2019), Sweden (Lee & Sylvén, 2021), and Hong Kong SAR (Liu, Ng, et al., 2024). This concentration matters because
access to informal digital language learning is shaped by the material and
educational conditions surrounding learners. In many parts of the Global South,
digital participation is expanding rapidly, yet learners may encounter uneven
connectivity, limited access to devices and paid digital services, and
considerable variation in the quality of formal language education (Liu & Hossain, 2026). Evidence derived predominantly from
well-resourced settings may therefore capture only some of the conditions under
which IDLL occurs.
The
Global South, however, should not be understood simply as a geographical
category or as a synonym for economically developing countries. It also
provides an epistemological perspective for examining how historical, economic,
and social inequalities shape whose experiences are represented in knowledge
production and whose remain peripheral (McCallum & Tafazoli, 2024; Pennycook & Makoni, 2019). From this
perspective, relevant contexts may include not only countries conventionally
classified as part of the geographical South, but also
marginalized communities and populations within wealthier societies. This
distinction is particularly important for IDLL because digital technologies are
often assumed to expand access to language-learning opportunities outside
formal education. Yet access alone does not ensure comparable opportunities for
learning. Learners also need reliable connectivity, appropriate devices,
digital literacies, relevant linguistic resources, and online content that they
can access and use (Lai
& Sundqvist, 2026; Soyoof
et al., 2026). IDLL may therefore create new opportunities while simultaneously
reproducing existing inequalities. Examining the Global South allows
researchers to investigate the conditions under which each possibility occurs
rather than assuming that digital access is inherently democratizing.
The
limited research conducted in less-resourced contexts already illustrates the
importance of attending to the relationship between learner agency and
structural conditions. Studies of rural university students in China, for
example, have shown how learners who were marginalized in urban educational
settings because of their accents and socioeconomic backgrounds used digital
spaces to develop alternative identities as legitimate English users and
accumulate forms of social and cultural capital that could be carried across
online and offline contexts (Liu,
2025a; Liu
& Darvin, 2024). In rural Bangladesh, Liu and Hossain’s (2026) survey of 508
university students found that IDLL participation was associated more strongly
with self-efficacy, enjoyment, and the ideal L2 self than with the demographic
and infrastructural variables included in their study. Prior IDLL experience
was also related to learners’ adoption of AI tools for out-of-class learning.
These findings demonstrate that learners exercise considerable agency even
under constrained conditions, but they should not be taken to mean that
individual motivation or confidence can simply compensate for structural
disadvantage. Rather, they raise an important question for future research: how
does learner agency interact with unequal access to material, social, and
digital resources in shaping IDLL?
This
question remains difficult to answer because evidence from the Global South is
still limited and unevenly distributed. Existing constructs and instruments
have often been developed and validated in comparatively well-resourced
educational settings, leaving uncertain whether they capture the conditions and
experiences of learners across Africa, Asia, Latin America, and the Middle East
(Lee, 2026; Liu & Darvin, 2024). Moreover,
considerable heterogeneity exists both across and within these regions.
National-level categories can obscure differences between urban and rural
learners, socioeconomic groups, educational institutions, and communities with
very different levels of digital access. Similar forms of marginalization may
also occur within the Global North. Rural and working-class learners in
high-income countries, for instance, can experience inequalities in access to
digital resources and educational opportunities (Warschauer, 2003). A Global South perspective
can therefore direct attention to structural positions and unequal
distributions of resources rather than treating national income or geographical
location as sufficient explanations of learners’ IDLL experiences.
Future
research should consequently move beyond simply adding more Global South
countries to the existing IDLL evidence base. The more consequential task is to
examine how local conditions reshape the processes and outcomes that current
IDLL theories seek to explain. This requires, first, greater attention to
whether established constructs and instruments are conceptually and culturally
appropriate in the settings in which they are used, rather than routinely
importing measures developed elsewhere (Pennycook & Makoni, 2019). Locally grounded
qualitative work can identify forms of participation, constraint, and learner
experience that existing scales may overlook, while subsequent quantitative
research can test whether these constructs operate similarly across contexts.
Comparative and multigroup studies can then examine variation not only across
countries but also across urban and rural settings, socioeconomic positions,
age groups, and educational backgrounds (Guo & Lee, 2023; Lee, 2026; Liu & Hossain, 2026).
Research
should also examine inequality as multidimensional rather than reducing it to
internet access or device ownership. Intersectional designs can investigate how
socioeconomic position, gender, geography, educational opportunity, language
background, and digital literacy combine to shape who can access particular forms of IDLL and what learners are able to do
with that access (cf. Soyoof
et al., 2026). Longitudinal and comparative work would be particularly useful for
determining whether IDLL reduces some inequalities while creating or
reinforcing others over time. Equally important is research on the strategies
learners and communities themselves develop under conditions of constraint,
including how they appropriate low-cost technologies, share resources, and
construct locally relevant digital learning practices.
Examining
the Global South, then, should do more than improve the geographical
representation of IDLL research. It provides an opportunity to reconsider
assumptions derived from well-resourced settings about access, autonomy,
learner agency, and the role of digital technology itself. By placing unequal
material and social conditions within the explanation of IDLL rather than
treating them as background variables, research can better determine when
digital language learning expands opportunities, when it reproduces existing
inequalities, and why these outcomes differ across learners and contexts.
The growing availability of digital technologies is
often assumed to expand opportunities for autonomous language learning, but
availability does not imply equal capacity to benefit from those opportunities.
Learners differ not only in whether they possess digital devices but also in
the resources, knowledge, dispositions, and social networks that allow them to
turn technologies into resources for language learning (Liu, Soyoof, et al., 2025). This distinction shifts the
question of inequality from whether learners can access technology to what they
are able to do with that access. Two learners using the same platform may
encounter very different possibilities depending on their digital literacies,
prior experiences, economic resources, and access to knowledgeable others.
Inequality in IDLL should therefore be understood not simply as a digital
divide between those who are connected and those who are not, but as
differences in learners’ capacity to convert digital access into opportunities
for language learning.
Social
class provides an important lens for understanding how these differences
develop. Learners accumulate unequal forms of economic, cultural, and social
capital through family resources, prior digital socialization, educational
experiences, and social networks, which in turn shape how confidently and
effectively they navigate informal digital environments (Liu & Darvin, 2026). Economic capital
may determine whether learners can pay for subscriptions or premium services;
cultural capital can shape their knowledge of which resources are useful and
how they should be used; and social capital can provide access to information, assistance,
and networks otherwise unavailable to them. These resources are also mutually
convertible. A learner with knowledgeable peers or transnational networks, for
example, may acquire information about tools and resources that another learner
with similar hardware cannot readily access. The inequality at stake is
therefore cumulative: advantages established before a particular IDLL activity
begins can shape which resources learners encounter, how they use them, and
what they subsequently gain from them.
The
rapid expansion of generative AI makes these differences particularly visible.
Liu and Darvin’s (2026) case study, for
example, contrasted two learners whose opportunities to use AI for language
learning differed despite both having access to digital technologies. Chen was
able to access ChatGPT through technical knowledge, overseas payment
credentials, and transnational networks and use it as a multilingual learning
resource, whereas Natalia relied on a domestic WeChat-based application with
character limits, advertisements, and more restricted functionality. The
contrast illustrates a layered form of digital inequality: hardware access
represents only one level, while platform access, technical knowledge, payment
capacity, and social networks determine the quality and range of resources
available thereafter. As AI systems increasingly differentiate between free and
paid tiers, informal language learning may become further stratified according
to who can access more capable models, longer interactions, advanced features,
and fewer usage restrictions (Liu
& Darvin, 2026).
Platform
design itself must therefore enter the analysis of inequality. IDLL does not
occur in technologically neutral spaces. Commercial platforms determine which
functions are free, which require payment, what content algorithms make
visible, and what users must exchange for access. Some ostensibly free
services, for instance, monetize participation through advertising or
peer-recruitment requirements (Liu
& Darvin, 2026). Such arrangements can convert economic
inequality into differences in learning experience: learners with greater
resources can purchase convenience, functionality, and choice, while those
relying on free services may encounter interruptions, restricted features, or
narrower forms of support. Inequality in IDLL is thus produced not only by
differences among learners but also through the commercial and technological
systems within which their learning takes place.
These
processes can be understood through theories that connect individual action
with social structure. Darvin and Norton’s (2015) model of investment, for
example, directs attention to the interaction among identity, capital, and
ideology in shaping whether learners are willing and able to invest in particular language practices. Applied to IDLL, this
perspective helps explain why formally identical digital opportunities can
generate unequal forms of participation. Learners enter digital spaces with
different resources and social positions, encounter platforms organized by particular economic and ideological logics, and may consequently
receive unequal returns on their investment. From this perspective, inequality
is not an external condition that merely influences IDLL; it can be reproduced
through the very processes by which learners access,
select, and use digital resources.
Yet
inequality remains comparatively peripheral in IDLL scholarship (Liu, Soyoof, et al., 2025). Much research
has examined learner-level predictors and outcomes without asking how these
variables themselves may be socially patterned. Digital competence,
self-efficacy, autonomy, and frequency of IDLL participation, for example, are
often modeled as individual characteristics, even though opportunities to
develop them may depend partly on learners’ prior access to economic, cultural,
and social resources. Treating these constructs only as individual differences
can therefore obscure the social conditions through which those differences
emerge. A stronger critical tradition in IDLL research would examine not only
whether learners differ, but how such differences are produced, accumulated,
and converted into unequal learning opportunities and outcomes.
Future
research should consequently move from documenting digital divides to
explaining the mechanisms through which advantage and disadvantage are
reproduced in IDLL. Social class deserves particular attention, with studies
examining how economic, cultural, and social capital independently and jointly
shape learners’ access to platforms, digital literacies, patterns of
participation, and learning outcomes (Liu, Soyoof, et al., 2025; Liu & Darvin, 2026). Longitudinal
research would be especially valuable for determining whether small initial
differences in resources accumulate over time: early access may foster digital
competence, which encourages greater participation, which may in turn generate
further linguistic and social resources. Conversely, limited early access may
constrain opportunities to develop the very capabilities needed for later
participation. Such work would allow researchers to examine inequality as a
developmental process rather than a static difference between groups.
The
rise of generative AI also creates a new set of questions about platform-based
inequality. Research should examine whether improvements in lower-cost and
locally available AI systems reduce disparities in access to high-quality
language-learning support or simply shift inequality from basic access to
differences in model quality, functionality, personalization, and user
expertise (Liu
& Darvin, 2026). Intervention research can complement this work
by testing whether measures such as subsidized access, targeted AI literacy
support, and institutional provision of digital resources reduce disparities in
learners’ opportunities to participate in IDLL (Liu, Soyoof, et al., 2025). Crucially, such
interventions should evaluate not only whether disadvantaged learners
participate more, but whether they gain access to comparable quality of
resources and comparable opportunities to benefit from them.
Interrogating
inequality therefore requires IDLL research to move beyond the binary question
of who has digital access. The more consequential issue is how resources and
advantages are converted across stages of informal digital learning: from
access to literacy, from literacy to participation, and from participation to
learning opportunities and outcomes. Examining these processes can reveal
whether IDLL disrupts existing social inequalities or provides new spaces
through which they are reproduced.
Individual differences (IDs)
have long occupied a central position in SLA research,
comprising relatively stable characteristics such as aptitude as well as
more dynamic factors such as motivation, anxiety, and self-efficacy (Dewaele,
2009; Li & Mizumoto, 2026; Li et al., 2022). The
expansion of language learning into everyday digital spaces introduces another
potentially consequential source of learner variation: the extent to which
learners independently seek, create, and use opportunities for language
learning outside formal instruction. Growing evidence suggests that
participating in IDLL may therefore be conceptualized as an emergent ID
variable that captures systematic differences in learners’ informal digital
practices and their relationship with L2 development (Liu,
Soyoof, et al., 2025; Sundqvist,
2024). Importantly, this conceptualization does not
treat IDLL as an inherent learner trait. Rather, it positions IDLL as a
behavioral and context-sensitive form of individual variation that develops
through interactions among learner characteristics, prior experiences, and
available digital opportunities.
Such a
positioning reflects broader changes in how IDs themselves are understood.
Contemporary ID research has increasingly moved away from viewing learner
characteristics as isolated and stable traits toward examining how they change
and interact with learning environments (Dewaele, 2009; Li et al., 2022). IDLL fits particularly well
within this dynamic view because learners differ substantially in whether, how
often, and in what ways they use digital resources for language learning, and
these differences can themselves change through experience. Research on
extramural English similarly suggests that, in highly digitalized settings,
out-of-class exposure and participation can constitute a substantial part of
learners’ language-learning experience and should therefore be considered when
explaining variation in proficiency (Sundqvist, 2024). IDLL thus differs from
conventional IDs in an important respect: it is simultaneously an outcome of
learner differences and a learning experience through which subsequent
differences may develop.
Existing
research provides growing evidence for the first side of this relationship.
Motivational theories, for example, help explain why some learners participate
more actively in IDLL than others. Within the L2 motivational self system,
discrepancies between learners’ current and imagined future selves can motivate
behaviors directed toward desired future identities (Dörnyei, 2009), providing one explanation
for why learners independently seek language-learning opportunities outside
formal settings. More recent research has begun to specify how different
motivational orientations relate to such practices. Drawing on regulatory focus
theory, Liu and Zhao (2026b) found among
Chinese learners of Malay that promotion-focused motivation directly predicted
informal digital learning of Malay, whereas prevention-focused motivation was
related to it indirectly through self-efficacy, which emerged as the strongest
direct predictor. Findings of this kind position IDLL not as incidental
technology use but as patterned behavior partly shaped by learners’
motivational and psychological characteristics.
The
relationship may also operate in the opposite direction. Participation in IDLL
can provide linguistic input, communicative experiences, feedback, and
opportunities for successful language use, which may subsequently reshape
learners’ proficiency, confidence, motivation, and other individual
characteristics. Liu and Soyoof’s (2026) meta-analysis of 47 studies,
for example, identified a positive association between IDLL and L2 achievement.
The predominantly cross-sectional evidence, however, makes it difficult to
determine whether learners achieve more because they participate more
extensively in IDLL, whether more proficient and motivated learners are more
likely to pursue IDLL, or whether these processes reinforce one another over
time. This reciprocal possibility is central to conceptualizing IDLL as an
emergent ID variable. IDLL may be both shaped by existing learner differences
and implicated in the development of new ones.
A
second conceptual issue concerns how this form of individual variation should
be represented. Much existing research operationalizes IDLL primarily through
frequency or amount of participation. Yet learners who report similar amounts
of IDLL may undertake substantially different activities and experience
different learning opportunities. Liu and Soyoof (2026) found that the magnitude of
the association between IDLL and L2 achievement was similar across different
measurement types, raising questions about whether frequency alone adequately
captures the dimensions of informal digital experience that matter for
learning. Zhang and Liu (2024) responded to this
problem by conceptualizing IDLE multidimensionally through IDLE practices,
others and support, authentic L2 experience, resources and cognition, frequency
and devices, and IDLE-enhanced benefits. Such work points toward a broader understanding
of learner variation in IDLL that concerns not only how much learners
participate but also what they do, with whom, through which resources, and
under what conditions.
Future
research should therefore examine IDLL as a dynamic component within a broader
system of individual differences rather than positioning it exclusively as
either predictor or outcome. One priority is to test reciprocal relationships
between IDLL and established IDs. For example, motivation or self-efficacy may
initially predict greater IDLL participation, while successful informal
experiences may subsequently strengthen motivation or self-efficacy, producing
feedback processes that unfold over time. A second priority is to establish
which dimensions of IDLL constitute consequential learner variation. Rather
than relying predominantly on aggregate frequency scores, researchers can
distinguish quantity from quality and composition, examining differences in
activity type, cognitive involvement, interaction, learner control, and
patterns of participation across digital spaces.
Positioning
IDLL as an emergent ID variable therefore does not mean adding another fixed
characteristic to the established inventory of learner differences. It instead
extends ID research to a form of behavioral variation that is produced through
learners’ interaction with their environments and can itself become a source of
subsequent variation. The central task for future research is to explain this
reciprocity: why learners develop different patterns of IDLL, how these
patterns change, and how accumulated informal digital experiences feed back
into the individual differences that initially shaped them.
Research has documented
associations between IDLL and a range of linguistic and non-linguistic
outcomes, including vocabulary (Lee, 2019), listening (Chen, 2024), reading (Liu & Darvin, 2024), speaking (Bin-Hady & Al-Tamimi, 2021), motivation (Liu, 2024), willingness to communicate, and self-efficacy (Zadorozhnyy
& Lee, 2025). Yet learners’ informal
digital experiences often remain disconnected from formal language education (Guo &
Lee, 2023; Lee et al., 2026; Soyoof et al., 2026). This
raises an important pedagogical question: how can formal instruction draw on
IDLL without turning self-directed practices into teacher-directed activities?
Bridging should therefore not mean absorbing IDLL into the curriculum, but
creating productive connections between formal and informal learning while
preserving learners’ locus of control. Teachers are particularly important as
boundary brokers who can recognize, respond to, and extend learners’ informal
digital experiences (Lai & Sundqvist, 2026).
Asset-based
pedagogy provides one basis for such connections by treating learners’ existing
knowledge and practices as resources rather than deficits (López, 2017). Soyoof et al. (2026), for example,
proposed a recognition-activation model in which teachers recognize learners’
informal digital literacies and draw on them for classroom reflection and
academic work. This approach resonates with bridging activities (Thorne & Reinhardt, 2008) and the
ethnographic-metacognitive approach, in which teachers guide learners in
examining relationships between their out-of-class digital practices and formal
language learning (Lai
& Sundqvist, 2026). The goal is thus not simply to introduce digital
resources into classrooms, but to connect learners’ existing informal
experiences with further language learning.
Teachers’
capacity and willingness to make these connections are consequently important.
In a survey of 1,008 teachers of English in China, Liu and Wang (2024) found that
intentions to integrate IDLL were associated with attitudes, subjective norms,
and perceived behavioral control, while teachers’ digital literacies and
technology experiences contributed to their perceived capacity for integration.
Zadorozhnyy and Yu (2023) similarly found
that preservice teachers who reconciled their identities as language learners
and teachers developed greater self-efficacy in designing personalized IDLL
tasks. Teacher support can also be orientational, through encouragement and
cognitive guidance, or behavioral, through incorporating digital resources into
teaching (Hoi & Mu, 2021). Together, these
findings position teachers not merely as technology users but as mediators
between learners’ formal and informal learning experiences.
Existing
research, however, has focused more on teachers’ perceptions and intentions
than on how bridging is actually enacted and
experienced (Lai & Sundqvist, 2026). Concrete
pedagogical designs remain insufficiently examined in terms of their
implementation and effects (Lai
& Sundqvist, 2026; Liu,
Ma, et al., 2025). A further conceptual issue concerns the boundary
of IDLL itself. As teacher direction increases, an activity may shift along the
dimensions of formality, pedagogy, and locus of control and become an
extracurricular extension of formal instruction rather than IDLL. Research
therefore needs to examine not only whether bridging occurs, but how teachers
can support learners’ informal practices without taking control of them.
Future
research should consequently move from teachers’ reported willingness to bridge
IDLL toward examining bridging as a pedagogical process. Design-based and
intervention studies can develop and compare approaches such as bridging
activities, recognition-activation, and ethnographic-metacognitive pedagogy,
while qualitative research can examine how teachers and learners negotiate
connections between learning contexts (Lai & Sundqvist, 2026; Soyoof et al., 2026). Particular attention should be given to whether classroom
support subsequently changes learners’ self-directed practices and whether
learners’ evolving IDLL experiences, in turn, influence classroom learning.
Such work would conceptualize bridging as a reciprocal relationship between
formal and informal learning rather than the one-way integration of IDLL into
the classroom.
Emerging technologies are
continually reshaping what learners can do in IDLL, making their changing
affordances an important direction for future research. Affordances are not
simply fixed properties of technologies but possibilities for action that emerge
through the relationship between technological features, learners, and the
contexts in which technologies are used (Pegrum, 2014). From this perspective, the same technology may offer different learning
possibilities depending on learners’ goals, competences, and patterns of use.
The central question is therefore not simply whether a new technology supports
language learning, but what forms of informal learning it makes possible, for
whom, and under what conditions.
Research
on mobile-assisted language learning provides an important foundation for
understanding such affordances. Portable technologies have been associated with
ubiquity, continuity, spontaneity, situatedness, connectivity, social
interactivity, and personalization, allowing language learning to occur across
locations and activities (Kukulska-Hulme,
2018; Reinders
& Benson, 2017). Generative AI extends these possibilities by
allowing learners not only to access linguistic resources but also to interact
with systems that generate responses, adapt input, provide feedback, and
simulate conversational partners. Zhang and Wan (2025), for example, found that
Chinese EFL learners used DeepSeek as both a tutor and conversation partner in
IDLL, with perceived usefulness strongly related to their use. Their findings
also highlighted prompt formulation as an important literacy through which
learners accessed the tool’s affordances. Similarly, Zhou et al.’s (2025) 16-week
quasi-experiment with 67 Chinese tertiary EFL students reported listening gains
associated with ChatGPT-4-supported IDLL, with learners identifying
interactivity, personalization, and individualized feedback as important
features of their experiences. Lower-achieving learners, however, experienced
greater extraneous cognitive load, illustrating that technological affordances
do not automatically translate into learning affordances.
This
distinction becomes especially important as AI takes on roles previously
associated primarily with human interlocutors and teachers. Unlike earlier
digital resources that largely provided access to content or communication,
generative AI can respond to learners, generate individualized materials,
explain language, and modify its output through continued interaction (Jeon, 2025). These
capabilities may change the nature of learner autonomy in IDLL. Learners
increasingly make decisions not only about which resources to consume but also
about what to ask, how to prompt, whether to trust generated responses, and how
to evaluate and revise AI output. Understanding AI-mediated IDLL therefore
requires attention to the literacies learners need to recognize and
productively take up technological affordances.
Affordances
also coexist with constraints. Learners using generative AI without teacher
oversight may encounter inaccurate information, problematic linguistic
feedback, or responses they are not equipped to evaluate critically (Meniado, 2026). AI systems may
also reproduce dominant linguistic and cultural representations while
inadequately representing marginalized languages and communities (Dovchin & Marlina, 2025). Rather than
treating affordances and constraints as separate properties, future research
should examine how they interact in actual learner practices. A feature that
benefits one learner may create cognitive, linguistic, or evaluative demands
for another, while an affordance may become available only after learners
develop the knowledge needed to recognize and use it.
Future
research should therefore shift from cataloguing technological features to
examining affordances-in-use. Studies can trace how learners actually
interact with emerging technologies through prompts, screen activity,
generated outputs, and subsequent learning actions, and examine how these
practices develop as learners become more familiar with particular
tools. Comparative research can also investigate how different
technological configurations produce different forms of IDLL, rather than
treating generative AI, mobile applications, social media, and other emerging
technologies as interchangeable digital resources. As technologies continue to
change, the more enduring research question is not which tool is most
effective, but how relationships among technological capabilities, learner
characteristics, and learning contexts generate particular
opportunities and constraints for informal language learning.
As mobile and social media
technologies and, more recently, generative AI expand what learners can do
autonomously, language learning beyond the classroom has become an increasingly
important dimension of contemporary language learning. IDLL can no longer be
treated simply as a peripheral complement to formal education. Its growing
prominence calls for stronger conceptual, theoretical, and empirical
foundations that can account for how informal digital learning differs across
learners, languages, technologies, and contexts.
The past decade has witnessed
considerable progress in documenting the linguistic and non-linguistic outcomes
associated with IDLL and in understanding learners’ self-directed practices
beyond the classroom. At the same time, the field remains fragmented and
unevenly developed. Its evidence base is disproportionately English-centric,
methodologically limited, and concentrated in relatively well-resourced settings.
Rapid technological change, particularly the rise of generative AI, further
complicates these issues by creating new possibilities for learning while
raising questions about access, inequality, learner agency, and the changing
relationship between informal and formal learning.
Against this backdrop, this paper has
proposed seven research directions grounded in a six-dimensional
conceptualization of language learning beyond the classroom. Together, these
directions call for a broader and more critical understanding of IDLL: one that
diversifies how it is studied, extends its linguistic and geographical scope,
examines learner and structural differences, strengthens connections with
formal instruction, and remains responsive to emerging technologies. We hope
this research agenda provides a useful basis for consolidating IDLL as a field
of inquiry while opening new questions about how, where, and under what
conditions informal digital practices contribute to language learning.
This study received no specific funding.
Not applicable, as this article does not involve original
empirical research with human participants.
Not applicable, as no human participants were recruited
for this article.
Not applicable, as no original empirical data were
collected or analyzed in this article.
The authors declare no conflicts of interest.
Arndt, H. L. (2023). Construction and validation
of a questionnaire to study engagement in informal second language learning. Studies
in Second Language Acquisition, 45(5), 1456–1480. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0272263122000572
Arndt, H. L., & Kusyk, M. (2026). Informal second language learning.
Language Teaching, 1–19. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0261444826101219
Benson, P. (2011). Language learning and teaching beyond the classroom: An
introduction to the field. In P. Benson & H. Reinders (Eds.), Beyond the
language classroom (pp. 7–16). London: Palgrave Macmillan. https://doi.org/10.1057/9780230306790_2
Bin-Hady, W. R. A., & Al-Tamimi, N. O. M. (2021). The use of
technology in informal English language learning: Evidence from Yemeni
undergraduate students. Learning and Teaching in higher education: Gulf Perspectives,
17(2), 107–120. https://doi.org/10.1108/LTHE-09-2020-0037
Bronfenbrenner, U. (1979). The ecology of human development: Experiments by nature
and design. Cambridge: Harvard University Press. https://doi.org/10.4159/9780674028845
Chen, C. W. Y. (2024). Lifelong informal language learning in the
digital age: An ecological perspective on three learners’ learning journeys. Pedagogies:
An International Journal, 19(1), 22–37. https://doi.org/10.1080/1554480X.2022.2124998
Chiswick, B. R., & Miller, P. W. (2005). Linguistic distance: A quantitative
measure of the distance between English and other languages. Journal of
Multilingual and Multicultural Development, 26(1), 1–11. https://doi.org/10.1080/14790710508668395
Darvin, R., & Norton, B. (2015). Identity and a model of investment
in applied linguistics. Annual Review of Applied Linguistics, 35,
36–56. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0267190514000191
Davis, F. D. (1989). Perceived usefulness, perceived ease of use, and user
acceptance of information technology. Management Information System
Quarterly, 13(3), 319–340. https://doi.org/10.2307/249008
Dewaele, J. M., & MacIntyre, P. D. (2016). Foreign language
enjoyment and foreign language classroom anxiety: The right and left feet of
the language learner. In P. D. MacIntyre, T. Gregersen & S. Mercer (Eds.), Positive
psychology in SLA (pp. 215–236). Clevedon: Multilingual Matters. https://doi.org/10.21832/9781783095360-010
Dovchin, S. & Marlina, R. (2025). Accent, access, and agency: A
conversation with professor Sender Dovchin on language and injustice. RELC Journal, 57(2),
454–460. https://doi.org/10.1177/00336882251351112
Dörnyei, Z. (2009). The L2 motivational self system. In Z. Dörnyei &
E. Ushioda (Eds.), Motivation, language identity and the L2 self (pp. 9–42).
Clevedon: Multilingual Matters. https://doi.org/10.21832/9781847691293-003
Dörnyei, Z., & Al-Hoorie, A. H. (2017). The motivational foundation
of learning languages other than global English: Theoretical issues and research
directions. The Modern Language Journal, 101, 455–468. https://doi.org/10.1111/modl.12408
Dressman,
M., & Sadler, R. W. (Eds.) (2020). The handbook of informal language learning.
Hoboken: Wiley-Blackwell. https://doi.org/10.1002/9781119472384
Gonen, S. I. K., & Kızılay, Y. (2023).
Taking the picture of informal digital learning of learning of English (IDLE)
in a higher education Turkish context. Turkish Online Journal of Distance
Education, 24(3), 178–191. https://izlik.org/JA32LW85NE
Guo, X., & Lee, J. S. (2023). A systematic review of informal digital
learning of English: An ecological systems theory perspective. System, 117,
1–14. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.system.2023.103097
Hoi, V. N., & Mu, G. M. (2021). Perceived teacher support and
students’ acceptance of mobile-assisted language learning: Evidence from
Vietnamese higher education context. British Journal of Educational
Technology, 52(2), 879–898. https://doi.org/10.1111/bjet.13044
Huang, S. C. (2019). Learning experience reigns –Taiwanese learners’ motivation in learning
eight additional languages as compared to English. Journal of Multilingual
and Multicultural Development, 40(7), 576–589. https://doi.org/10.1080/01434632.2019.1571069
Jenkins, J. (2006). Current perspectives on teaching world English and
English as a lingua franca. TESOL Quarterly, 40(1), 157–181. https://doi.org/10.2307/40264515
Jenkins, J. (2013). English as a lingua franca in the international
university: The politics of academic English language policy (1st ed). London:
Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9780203798157
Jeon, E. Y. (2025). Artificial intelligence in ESL/EFL education:
Evidence from recent reviews (2024-2025). International Journal of Learning,
Teaching and Educational Research, 24(10), 509–526. https://doi.org/10.26803/ijlter.24.10.24
Khanh-Quynh, T. T., & Ngo, C.-L. (2026). The new writing partner?
EFL students’ real-time use of GenAI tools in academic composing. Applied Language Sciences, 2(1). https://doi.org/10.65553/ALS.260107
Kukulska-Hulme, A. (2018). Mobile-assisted
language learning [revised and updated version]. In C. A. Chapelle (Ed.), The
concise encyclopedia of applied linguistics (pp. 1–9). Hoboken: Wiley. https://doi.org/10.1002/9781405198431.wbeal0768.pub2
Kukulska-Hulme, A. (2021). Reflections
on research questions in mobile assisted language learning. Journal of China
Computer-Assisted Language Learning, 1(1), 28–46. https://doi.org/10.1515/jccall-2021-2002
Kusyk, M., Arndt, H. L., Schwarz, M., Yibokou, K. S., Dressman, M.,
Sockett, G., & Toffoli, D. (2025). A scoping review of studies in informal
second language learning: Trends in research published between 2000 and 2020. System,
130, 103541. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.system.2024.103541
Lai, C., & Gu, M. (2011). Self-regulated out-of-class language
learning with technology. Computer Assisted Language Learning, 24(4),
317–335. https://doi.org/10.1080/09588221.2011.568417
Lai, C., & Sundqvist, P. (2026). Research agenda: Synergizing
in-class and out-of-class language learning with technology. Language
Teaching, 59(1), 60–81. https://doi.org/10.1017/S026144482500014X
Lee, J. S. (2019). Informal digital learning of English and second
language vocabulary outcomes: Can quantity conquer quality? British Journal
of Educational Technology, 50(2), 767–778. https://doi.org/10.1111/bjet.12599
Lee, J. S. (2022). Informal digital learning of English: Research to
practice. New York: Routledge.
Lee, J. S. (2025). Innovation in language learning and teaching for
social impact. In H. Nesi & P. Milin (Eds.), International encyclopedia
of language and linguistics (3rd ed.) (pp. 1–5). Amsterdam: Elsevier. https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-323-95504-1.00433-6
Lee, J. S. (2026). Informal digital learning of English.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. https://doi.org/10.1017/9781009641647
Lee, J. S., & Chiu, M. M. (2023). Modeling EFL learners’ willingness
to communicate: The roles of face-to-face and digital L2 communication anxiety.
Annual Review of Applied Linguistics, 43, 64–87. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0267190523000090
Lee, J. S., & Dressman, M. (2018). When IDLE hands make an English
workshop: Informal digital learning of English and language proficiency. TESOL
Quarterly, 52(2), 435–445. https://www.jstor.org/stable/44986999
Lee, J. S., & Sylvén, L. K. (2021). The role of informal digital learning
of English in Korean and Swedish EFL learners’ communication behaviour. British
Journal of Educational Technology, 52(3), 1279–1296. https://doi.org/10.1111/bjet.13082
Lee, Y.-J., Parrila, R., & Colenbrander, D. (2026). Adopt, adapt, or
reject? Analysing student-AI interaction in university curriculum-aligned
writing tasks. Applied
Language Sciences, 2(1), 260102. https://doi.org/10.65553/ALS.260102
Li, O., & Mizumoto, A. (2026). Measuring
autonomous and efficacious GenAI use and GenAI reliance in EFL learning:
Initial scale development and validation. Applied
Language Sciences, 2(1). https://doi.org/10.65553/ALS.260116
Li, S., Hiver, P., & Papi, M. (Eds.). (2022). The Routledge handbook
of second language acquisition and Individual Differences (1st ed.). New
York: Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781003270546
Liu, G. L. (2024). Modeling L2 motivation change and its predictive
effects on learning behaviors in the extramural digital context: A quantitative
investigation in China. Linguistics Vanguard, 10(1), 1–12. https://doi.org/10.1515/lingvan-2023-0145
Liu, G. L. (2025a). Digital empowerment for rural migrant students in
China: Identity, investment, and digital literacies beyond the classroom. ReCALL,
37(2), 215–231. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0958344024000302
Liu, G. L., & Darvin, R. (2024). From rural China to the digital wilds:
Negotiating digital repertoires to claim the right to speak. TESOL Quarterly,
58(1), 334–362. https://doi.org/10.1002/tesq.3233
Liu, G. L., & Darvin, R. (2026). Social class, generative AI, and
the negotiation of unequal digital literacies. Language Teaching Research,
1–23. https://doi.org/10.1177/13621688261441794
Liu, G. L., & Hossain, M. K. (2026). What predicts (AI-Mediated)
informal digital learning of English in the Global South? The case of rural
Bangladeshi students. Journal of Computer Assisted Learning, 42(2),
Article e70196. https://doi.org/10.1002/jcal.70196
Liu, G. L., & Lee, J. S. (2026). AI-mediated informal digital
learning of English. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. https://doi.org/10.1017/9781009742542
Liu,
G. L., & Ma, C. (2024). Measuring EFL learners’ use of ChatGPT in informal
digital learning of English based on the technology acceptance model. Innovation
in Language Learning and Teaching, 18(2), 125–138. https://doi.org/10.1080/17501229.2023.2240316
Liu, G. L., Ma, C., Bao, J.,
& Liu, Z. (2025). Toward a model of informal digital learning of English
and intercultural competence: A large-scale structural equation modeling
approach. Computer Assisted Language Learning, 38(3), 342–368. https://doi.org/10.1080/09588221.2023.2191652
Liu, G. L., Ng, K. H., &
Gonzales, W. D. W. (2024). The predictive role of L2 motivation in receptive
and productive informal digital learning of English: A chain mediation model. Digital
Applied Linguistics, 1, 2229. https://doi.org/10.29140/dal.v1.2229
Liu, G. L., & Soyoof, A. (2026). Does
informal digital language learning really contribute to second language
achievement? Evidence from a multilevel meta-analysis. System, 139,
Article 104036. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.system.2026.104036
Liu,
G. L., Soyoof, A., Lee, J. S., & Zhang, L. J. (2025). Informal digital
learning of English in Asian English as a foreign language contexts: A thematic review. RELC Journal, 1–8. https://doi.org/10.1177/00336882251332309
Liu, G. L., & Wang, Y. (2024). Modeling
EFL teachers’ intention to integrate informal digital learning of English
(IDLE) into the classroom using the theory of planned behavior. System, 120,
Article 103193. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.system.2023.103193
Liu,
G. L, Zhang, Y., & Zhang, R. (2024). Examining the relationships among
motivation, informal digital learning of English, and foreign language
enjoyment: An explanatory mixed-method study. ReCALL, 36(1),
72–88. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0958344023000204
Liu, G. L., & Zhao, X. (2026a). A scoping
review of AI-mediated informal language learning: Mapping out the terrain and
identifying future directions. ReCALL, 38(1), 111–130. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0958344025100359
Liu, G. L., & Zhao, X. (2026b). Informal digital learning of Malay
among L3 learners in China: The role of learner motivation and self-efficacy. Journal
of Multilingual and Multicultural Development, 1–20. https://doi.org/10.1080/01434632.2026.2699946
Liu, G. L., Zhao, X., & Yang, B. (2024). The predictive effects of
motivation, enjoyment, and self-efficacy on informal digital learning of LOTE:
Evidence from French and German learners in China. System, 126,
Article 103504. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.system.2024.103504
López, F. A. (2017). Altering the trajectory
of the self-fulfilling prophecy: Asset-based pedagogy and classroom dynamics. Journal
of Teacher Education, 68(2), 193–212. https://doi.org/10.1177/0022487116685751
Lu, J., & Shen, Q. (2022).
Understanding China’s LOTE learners’ perceptions and choices of LOTE(s) and
English learning: A linguistic market perspective. Current Issues in
Language Planning, 23(4), 394–411. https://doi.org/10.1080/14664208.2021.2005383
McCallum, L., & Tafazoli, D.
(Eds.). (2024). Computer-assisted language learning in the Global South:
Exploring challenges and opportunities for students and teachers. London:
Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781003495956
Mendoza, A., & Phung, H. (2019).
Motivation to learn languages other than English: A critical research
synthesis. Foreign Language Annals, 52(1), 121–140. https://doi.org/10.1111/flan.12380
Meniado, J. C. (2026). Artificial intelligence pollution in digital
environments: Mitigating adverse impacts on language education through
multiliteracies integration. RELC Journal, 57(2), 287–295. https://doi.org/10.1177/00336882261458037
Pegrum,
M. (2014). Mobile learning. Languages, literacies and cultures. London:
Palgrave Macmillan.
Pennycook, A., & Makoni, S. (Eds). (2019). Innovations and
challenges in applied linguistics from the Global South. London: Routledge. http://hdl.handle.net/10453/136676
Phillipson,
R. (2008). The linguistic imperialism of neoliberal empire. Critical Inquiry
in Language Studies, 5(1), 1–43. https://doi.org/10.1080/15427580701696886
Reinders,
H., & Benson, P. (2017). Research agenda: Language learning beyond the
classroom. Language Teaching, 50(4), 561–578. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0261444817000192
Reinders,
H., Lai, C., & Sundqvist, P. (2022). Introduction: Language learning &
teaching beyond the classroom. In H. Reinders, C. Lai & P. Sundqvist
(Eds.), The Routledge handbook of language learning & teaching beyond
the classroom (pp. 1–6). London: Routledge.
Rezai, A., Soyoof, A., & Reynolds, B. L. (2024). Informal digital
learning of English and EFL teachers’ job engagement: Exploring the mediating
role of technological pedagogical content knowledge and digital competence. System,
122, 1–16. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.system.2024.103276
Sauro,
S., & Zourou, K. (2019). What are the digital wilds? Language Learning and
Technology, 23(1), 1–7. https://doi.org/10.64152/10125/44666
Sockett,
G. (2011). From the cultural hegemony of English to online informal learning:
Cluster frequency as an indicator of relevance in authentic documents. ASp,
60, 5–20. https://doi.org/10.4000/asp.2469
Soyoof,
A., Lee, J. S., & Liu, G. L. (2026), Informal digital learning of English
(IDLE) as an innovative pedagogy: A catalyst for holistic language development
and sustainable global impact. Journal of Computer Assisted Learning, 42,
Article e70237. https://doi.org/10.1002/jcal.70237
Soyoof,
A., Reynolds, B. L., Vazquez-Calvo, B., & McLay, K. (2023). Informal
digital learning of English (IDLE): A scoping review of what has been done and
a look towards what is to come. Computer Assisted Language Learning, 36(4),
608–640. https://doi.org/10.1080/09588221.2021.1936562
Sundqvist,
P. (2009). Extramural English matters: Out-of-school English and its impact on
Swedish ninth graders’ oral proficiency and vocabulary [Unpublished doctoral
dissertation]. Karlstad University.
Sundqvist, P. (2024). Extramural English as an individual difference variable
in L2 research: Methodology matters. Annual Review of Applied Linguistics,
44, 79–91. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0267190524000072
Sundqvist,
P., & Sylvén, L. K. (2016). Extramural English in teaching and learning:
From theory and research to practice. London: Palgrave Macmillan. https://doi.org/10.1057/978-1-137-46048-6
Takahashi, J., & Harumi, S. (2026). Creating parallel
translanguaging side spaces: Pursuing meaning-conveyance and mutual
comprehension via multiple technology use in an e-tandem program. Applied Language Sciences, 2(1). https://doi.org/10.65553/ALS.260114
Thorne,
S. L., & Reinhardt, J. (2008). “Bridging activities,” new media literacies,
and advanced foreign language proficiency. CALICO Journal, 25(3),
558–572. https://doi.org/10.1558/cj.v25i3.558-572
Trinder,
R. (2017). Informal and deliberate learning with new technologies. ELT
Journal (English Language Teaching Journal), 71(4), 401–412. https://doi.org/10.1093/elt/ccw117
Ushioda,
E., & Dörnyei, Z. (2017). Beyond global English: Motivation to learn
languages in a multicultural world: Introduction to the special issue. The
Modern Language Journal, 101(3), 451–454. https://doi.org/10.1111/modl.12407
Warschauer,
M. (2003). Technology and social inclusion: Rethinking the digital divide.
Cambridge: The MIT Press. https://doi.org/10.7551/mitpress/6699.001.0001
Woore,
R., Molway, L., & Savory, C. (2026). Motivation for learning Chinese
compared to European languages: An exploration in English secondary schools. Foreign
Language Annals, 59(1), 278–300. https://doi.org/10.1111/flan.70050
Zadorozhnyy,
A., & Lee, J. S. (2025). Informal digital learning of English and
willingness to communicate in a second language: Self-efficacy beliefs as a
mediator. Computer Assisted Language Learning, 38(4), 669–689. https://doi.org/10.1080/09588221.2023.2215279
Zadorozhnyy,
A., & Yu, B. (2023). Preservice English language teachers and informal
digital learning of English (IDLE) in Kazakhstan. In D. Toffoli, G. Sockett,
& M. Kusyk (Eds.), Language learning and leisure: Informal language
learning in the digital age (pp. 269–289). Berlin: De Gruyter Mouton. https://doi.org/10.1515/9783110752441-012
Zhang,
Y., & Liu, G. L. (2024). Revisiting informal digital learning of English
(IDLE): A structural equation modeling approach in a university EFL context. Computer
Assisted Language Learning, 37(7), 1904–1936. https://doi.org/10.1080/09588221.2022.2134424
Zhang,
Y., & Wan, F. W. (2025). Investigating AI-mediated informal digital
learning of English (AI-Idle): The adoption and experiences of Chinese EFL
learners with Deepseek. International Journal of Research and Innovation in
Social Science, 9(9), 4231–4240. https://dx.doi.org/10.47772/IJRISS.2025.909000345
Zhao,
X., Liu, G. L., Eerdemutu, L., & Shirvan, M. E. (2026). Do shyness and
emotions matter in shaping classroom engagement? A study of multilingual
learners of Chinese in Thailand. Journal of Multilingual and Multicultural
Development, 47(6), 3827–3845. https://doi.org/10.1080/01434632.2025.2539922
Zhao,
X., Wang, S., Zhang, Y., & Liu, G. L. (2026). Boredom profiles, digital
competence, and informal digital learning of Chinese among New Zealand
adolescents: A person-centered approach. Studies in Second Language Learning
and Teaching, 1–28. https://doi.org/10.14746/ssllt.53127
Zhou,
Q., Hashim, H., & Sulaiman, N. A. (2025). Integrating AI chatbots in
informal digital English learning: Impacts on listening competencies in Chinese
higher education. Education and Information Technologies, 30, 27031–27059. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10639-025-13811-2
Chaohai Xue (MA, Southeast University) is a PhD student in Foreign Linguistics and
Applied Linguistics at the School of Foreign Languages, Southeast University,
China. His research interests include AI-mediated informal language learning
and digital literacies.
E-mail: haichaoxue@126.com
ORCID: 0009-0006-7494-7397
Guangxiang Leon Liu (PhD, The Chinese University of Hong Kong) is Professor (research-track) at
the School of Foreign Languages, Southeast University, China. His research
interests include AI-mediated informal language learning and digital
literacies. Recognized among Stanford University’s top 2% most-cited
scientists, he has published widely in leading international peer-reviewed
journals such as Computers
in Human Behavior, System, TESOL Quarterly, ReCALL, and Computer Assisted Language Learning. He is a recipient of the 2024 AILA Solidarity Award.
E-mail: g.liu@seu.edu.cn
ORCID: 0000-0002-5361-268X