Conceptual Foundations in Language
Research
Conceptual Foundations in Language
Research, 1, 260106 (2026)
https://doi.org/10.65553/CFLR.260106
Translanguaging
as Transformative Practice: Implications for Contemporary Language Classrooms
Martin East*
The University of Auckland, New
Zealand
Abstract
Translanguaging has emerged as a significant concept
in the field of applied linguistics, and a wide range of publications and
presentations has examined its implications for educational systems and
classroom instruction. Translanguaging signifies a potentially transformative
practice for additional language (L2) classrooms because it enables the
strategic deployment of linguistic and non-linguistic resources, both within
and beyond the L2, to facilitate effective communication. However,
translanguaging challenges established practices and paradigms in both language
pedagogy and language research because it contradicts the traditional ‘monolingual principle’ that maximum use of the target language is necessary
to enhance second language acquisition. This Perspectives paper, derived from a
keynote at a recent conference at the University of Macau, sets out to address
the implications for translanguaging as transformative practice by exploring
arguments for and against translanguaging. In light of these arguments, it
draws some conclusions for how translanguaging may be implemented in L2
classrooms.
Keywords: translanguaging; L2 classrooms; transformative practice; effective communication; the monolingual principle
The phenomenon of translanguaging
is described by Brooks (2022) as “one of the most
influential concepts in the field of applied and sociolinguistics” (pp. 129-130). Its strong influence, according to
Brooks, is evidenced by the wide range of publications and presentations
examining its implications for educational systems and classroom instruction,
to the point that almost everyone working in language teaching is likely to
have encountered the term.
Pedagogically, translanguaging
signifies a potentially transformative practice for additional language (L2)
classrooms. It empowers learners to draw on their first language (L1) when
necessary to convey meaning and may also involve the strategic use of extra-linguistic
resources, such as body language, gestures, and visual aids, as learners
exploit whatever resources are available to them to negotiate meaning
successfully and facilitate effective communication. However, translanguaging
challenges established practices and paradigms in both language pedagogy and
language research. This is because it contradicts the traditional ‘monolingual principle’ (Howatt,
1984) that, since the main goal of learning an L2 is to become proficient in
that language – the target language
or TL – maximum use of the TL is
necessary to enhance second language acquisition (SLA).
The antithesis between multimodal
translanguaging and monolingual language use leads to a tension in practice:
whether translanguaging is offering a panacea to the challenges of learning an
L2 in contemporary classrooms or whether it is a questionable practice that
should be avoided in L2 classrooms. In light of this tension, it is perhaps “unsurprising that translanguaging as pedagogic
innovation has both captured the academic imagination and [led to] a few raised
eyebrows in equal measure, not least for the associated claims of ‘transformation’” (Brooks, 2022, p. 131).
What, then, are the implications
for translanguaging as transformative practice in contemporary L2 classrooms?
This Perspectives paper, derived from a keynote I presented at a conference
hosted and organised recently by the University of Macau Faculty of Education (East, 2026), sets out to address
this question.
Arguments
for Translanguaging
Forces of globalisation and
increases in human mobility mean that classroom dynamics are rapidly changing
all over the world and homogeneous classes are no longer normative.
Translanguaging has been proposed as one means of effectively handling the
emerging multilingual and multicultural realities of this super-diversity (see,
e.g., Hofer
& Jessner, 2026). Table 1 presents several contemporary definitions
of the concept.
The definitions presented in
Table 1 highlight several core features of translanguaging. In L2 classrooms,
it allows for the use of students’ L1 alongside the TL
so that students’ understanding and
achievement can be maximised. However, translanguaging is more than just
admitting L1 use. It reflects an ideological and paradigmatic shift away from
viewing languages as discrete, bounded systems towards a more holistic
conception of language as an integrated repertoire available to each
individual. Moreover, translanguaging acknowledges that effective multilingual
interactions encompass various modes of communication (García & Li, 2014).
Table 1. Definitions of Translanguaging
|
Reference |
Definition
|
|
East
and D. Wang (2025) |
“the phenomenon whereby users of language
draw on linguistic and non-linguistic resources both in and beyond the TL to
sustain or enhance the communicative effectiveness of what they are trying to
communicate” (p. 703). |
|
Dovchin
and M. Wang (2024) |
Using “all available linguistic resources
freely and flexibly to transition and shuttle between, among, and beyond
languages through multiple semiotic modes, codes, genres, and other
(non)linguistic resources for advertent [intentional] or sometimes inadvertent
(non)academic engagement and communication in formal and informal settings”
(p. 429). |
|
Tai
(2024) |
“the strategic and spontaneous use of a
participant’s linguistic and semiotic repertoire in a unified manner during
the meaning-making process, without distinguishing between different
languages as separate codes” (p. 553). |
According to Dovchin and Wang (2024), the considerable
benefits of translanguaging have been not only “theoretically argued and empirically proven” but have also demonstrated “transformative and
constructive potential.” They suggested that
this potential is seen in dimensions such as fostering learner agency and
inclusion, promoting equity and linguistic justice, and transforming power
relations and dynamics due to access to “rich and equal educational and linguistic resources” (p. 430).
Importantly, translanguaging is
authentic. As a means of responding to the realities of multilingual and
superdiverse contexts, it mirrors the ways in which teachers and learners may
often use language in genuine interactions both in and beyond the L2 classroom.
This kind of spontaneous translanguaging is
exemplified in the natural and unprompted use of a range of communicative
resources that interlocutors might draw on in everyday life and incorporates
strategies that individuals from diverse linguistic backgrounds have long
employed, to varying degrees, to sustain interaction when communication
difficulties arise.
Emphasising the authentic nature
of translanguaging, Bui and Tai (2022) argued that the goal of L2 learning is not to become monolingual in
the L2 but, rather, to become bilingual or multilingual. From this perspective,
translanguaging is operating as a transformative practice due to its challenge
to TL-only policies and the monolingual assumptions and ideologies that
underpin them, and pedagogical translanguaging
becomes one means through which L2 teachers can exploit the range of
communicative resources available to L2 learners in deliberate and strategic
ways (e.g., Cenoz
& Gorter, 2021).
Arguments
against Translanguaging
Despite arguments in favour of
translanguaging in L2 classrooms, translanguaging challenges current practices
and paradigms in both language pedagogy and language research precisely because
it brings into question the established principle that the ultimate objective
of learning an additional language is, above all else, to develop proficiency
in that language. For this reason, translanguaging as transformative practice
may be resisted or avoided by both teachers and learners.
In the introduction to an edited
volume whose published purpose was to explore transparently the use of language
learners’ L1 in L2 classrooms, Turnbull
and Dailey-O’Cain (2009) argued that, despite
the benefits that L1 use might have, it should be taken as self-evident that “the ultimate goal of a second or foreign language
classroom remains the learning of the target language” such that “practices that
undermine this ultimate goal must be avoided” (p. 2). Littlewood and Yu (2011) maintained that the
monolingual principle “has permeated every
language teaching method that has found widespread official support” due to its focus on using the TL as “the normal means of classroom communication” (p. 64). Although arguing in favour of the positive
place that translanguaging may have in L2 classrooms, both Li (2018) and Bui and Tai (2022) drew attention to
TL-only or ‘one-language-at-a-time’ as ideologies that still continue to dominate language
teaching and learning practices in many domains.
Despite the positive benefits of
translanguaging identified by Dovchin and Wang (2024), they maintained that, from the
students’ perspective, translanguaging
might be strongly resisted
in
some situations by those who, in other circumstances, might draw on it in their
everyday lives. This resistance might be particularly evident in educational
contexts such as language classrooms, being “deeply provoked by the impact of pervasive language ideology” (p. 430) – what Dovchin and Wang
described as ‘native speaker
saviorism’ (Jenks & Lee, 2020). In their specific
context (the Australian context where Standard Australian English is considered
the norm and the goal of English as L2 classrooms), a monolingual ideology
served to elevate the status of English to the extent that otherwise spontaneous
translanguagers would valorise its use so as to fit into the dominant
Anglophone society. Dovchin and Wang concluded:
while we stand in solidarity with
fellow applied linguists who advocate for translanguaging, we also remind our
colleagues that many actual translanguagers in certain social scenarios still
carry enduring skepticism about the benefits of translanguaging. (p. 430)
When it comes to measuring learners’ L2 proficiency, language assessment remains effectively focused on
learners’ compliance with TL norms, rather
than their ability to draw creatively and flexibly on their multilingual
repertoires to communicate effectively in real-world settings (Bui & Tai, 2022). Translanguaging in
assessment is therefore not part of the mainstream dialogue, and language
assessments are “often explicitly
anti-translanguaging” (Schissel et al., 2021, p. 342). Shohamy (2011) maintained that such
assessments are based on “a monolingual,
homogenous, and often still native-like construct” (p. 419) that “forbid[s] any other
languages to ‘smuggle in’” (p. 421). Where monolingual practices persist,
particularly in relation to high-stakes examinations such as the International
English Language Testing System (IELTS) or the Test of English as a Foreign
Language (TOEFL), the aspirations of language learners to pass these
examinations and the consequent washback into language classes will continue to
have a constraining effect on adopting translanguaging practices in L2
classrooms.
Mediating
the Tension
The above exploration of the
essential tension between embracing translanguaging in L2 classrooms as a “new linguistic reality” (García
& Li, 2014, p. 29) and limiting or excluding translanguaging in L2
classrooms to uphold the principle of TL use leads to the conclusion that
translanguaging is not “a simple pedagogical
choice open to anyone that wants to use it” (Nagashima
& Lawrence, 2022, p. 751). One means of reconciling the
tension is to recognise that translanguaging is not an absolute, which means
that pedagogical practice is not a simple dichotomy of either admitting
translanguaging (wholesale adoption) or excluding translanguaging (wholesale
rejection).
One recent study illustrates both
the tension and a means of addressing it. It explored the benefits and
implications of translanguaging in a context that, although not specifically an
L2 classroom, was informed by the core premise of using English as the TL to
maximise acquisition (i.e., the monolingual principle) – an English Medium Instruction (EMI) Year 7 History classroom in Hong
Kong (Tai,
2024; Tai
& Li, 2025). The teacher, although proficient in English, was an
L1 Cantonese speaker. The students (n =
30) had below-average English proficiency in comparison with their peers.
In the study, translanguaging was
conceptualised as “an inclusive pedagogy
for engaging students in classroom learning” (Tai
& Li, 2025, p. 195). Classroom observations revealed that, on the one
hand, the teacher aimed to use English as the language of instruction in
accordance with the school’s language policy
expectations. On the other hand, he utilised translanguaging as “a multimodal form of pedagogical practice without involving students’ L1” (Tai, 2024, p. 576, my emphasis) by
drawing on gestures, pictures, and body language. In this way, Tai argued that
the teacher augmented the students’ learning by
successfully creating room for translanguaging in a classroom informed by a
rigid TL-only language policy.
Reflecting on the evidence
available from the EMI study in Hong Kong, Tai and Li (2025) concluded that a classroom can
be conceptualised as an
integrated translanguaging space – that is, a space in
which translanguaging practices can occur. This conceptualisation provides the
room to move practice beyond deliberate strategies to support learners
(pedagogical translanguaging) to what Li (e.g., 2024) described as translanguaging pedagogy which focuses more
broadly on translanguaging principles such as recognising and respecting
students’ linguistic and cultural
backgrounds and creating safe and inclusive classrooms that encourage all
students to participate. Within this overarching integrated space, distinct translanguaging sub-spaces can be created to
provide opportunities for translanguaging to occur (or not occur) at different
times and in different ways, prompted by different communicative needs.
As for putting translanguaging
into practice in the sub-spaces suggested by Tai and Li (2025), Bonacina-Pugh et
al. (2021) suggested that
translanguaging in practice can be viewed as operating in two forms: weak (or
fixed) translanguaging which is manifested “when speakers are inclined to soften the barriers between languages
whilst still acknowledging the existence of these languages as separate
entities;” and strong (or fluid)
translanguaging which is manifested “when speakers
acknowledge that they use one single repertoire made up of a variety of
semiotic resources” (p. 442).
However, Bonacina-Pugh et al.’s (2021) binary perspective does not acknowledge the dominant influence of the
monolingual principle. The weak/strong distinction characterises
translanguaging in terms of speakers’ orientations towards
language boundaries – whether they relax
those boundaries or dissolve them altogether. It does not address the
institutional conditions under which such orientations may be enacted. In L2
classrooms, the abiding reality is that choices about language use are shaped
by language policies, curriculum expectations, and the washback effect of
high-stakes assessments, all of which may continue to privilege the TL. In
these conditions, a teacher who holds a fluid view of language would still be
required to maintain TL-only practices for particular purposes or at particular
times. What is needed, therefore, is a model that can accommodate not only
different orientations to translanguaging but also the movement between more
and less monolingual practices that institutional constraints may make
necessary.
Broadening out the concept of a
binary form of translanguaging (weak or strong), Anderson (e.g., 2018) spoke of a continuum
of practice that accounts for classroom environments that
range from “wholly monolingual” at one end to “highly translingual” at the other, alongside “the ability to move flexibly along the translingual continuum depending
on context and interlocutor(s)” (p. 32). This
understanding of translanguaging in practice would enable L2 teachers to
maintain sub-spaces that are wholly dedicated to using the TL alongside sub-spaces that admit all communicative repertoires. This
provides considerable room for teacher and learner experimentation.
Theorising a Continuum
Viewing translanguaging as a
continuum is more than a practical attempt to bridge opposing positions. It
shifts attention to a deeper theoretical issue: two different accounts of what
language learning is for and how it happens. The monolingual principle rests on
a cognitive-interactionist view in which acquisition is driven by exposure to,
and pushed production in, the TL. From this perspective, every turn in another
language is a lost opportunity for input or output. Translanguaging rests on a
sociocultural and semiotic view in which learning is mediated by all the
resources a learner brings. From this perspective, learning is not understood
solely in terms of TL performance measured against monolingual L1 speaker norms
but, importantly, in terms of learners’
capacity to deploy their full semiotic repertoire to communicate and
participate effectively across contexts. These theoretical standpoints need not
be treated as antithetical. Each captures a different function of classroom
language use: the TL as the object of learning, and the full repertoire as the
means of mediating it.
Taking different functions of
classroom language use into account, the continuum becomes a principle for
allocating resources for specific purposes. Sub-spaces at the monolingual end
support an acquisition-oriented pedagogical aim that maximises opportunities
for input, output, and interaction in the TL; sub-spaces towards the
translingual end support a mediational aim that maximises the support available
from a broader communicative repertoire. The Hong Kong EMI study is instructive
precisely because the teacher’s translanguaging did
not involve the students’ L1 (Tai, 2024). It demonstrates
that the opposition between monolingual and translingual practice is less
absolute than the debate often assumes: TL use and the strategic use of the
wider semiotic repertoire can occur together.
Task-based language teaching
offers one concrete illustration of how a continuum view of translanguaging
informed by sub-spaces might work (East & Wang, 2025). In a task cycle, the pre-task phase may
admit the full repertoire as learners plan and make sense of the task; the main
task phase may exploit TL use but it may also allow learners to draw on other
resources if necessary when communication breaks down, in keeping with a view
of task success as functional adequacy (Bui & Tai, 2022); a post-task focus
on form may be executed according to the needs of the students. The decision is
no longer whether to translanguage, but
when,
why,
and to
what extent – a decision that teachers can
make explicit and can justify to learners. This principled view responds
directly to the arguments against translanguaging. It accepts that TL
development remains a central goal, as Turnbull and Dailey-O’Cain (2009) insisted, while questioning the assumption that this goal is best
served by excluding everything else.
A
Call to Action
This Perspectives paper has
presented several arguments both for and against translanguaging in the context
of educational practice. It has identified genuine tensions that led Brooks (2022) to assert that
translanguaging provokes both considerable interest and sincere questioning and
led Dovchin and Wang (2024) to identify both substantial benefits of and significant constraints
to translanguaging in practice. These tensions remain. If translanguaging is to
become more readily embraced in practice as a transformative means of
countering monolingually oriented L2 classrooms, the persistent tensions call
for further theoretical, empirical, and practical work to evaluate and critique
the role of translanguaging in contemporary L2 classrooms and to further
determine what benefits (and limitations) ensue. This ongoing work will
continue to have implications for contemporary practice. In the meantime, a
continuum understanding of translanguaging provides not only a theoretically
defensible and practical way forward but also a potential foundation for
further research.
Acknowledgment
My
grateful thanks to Mark Feng Teng, not only for inviting me to contribute this
Perspectives piece to Conceptual Foundations in Language
Research but also for his cogent and
thought-provoking feedback, which enhanced the manuscript.
Declarations
Declaration of competing interest.
The author declares no competing interests.
CRediT authorship contribution
statement:
Conceptualisation, writing, review,
and editing.
Anderson, J. (2018). Reimagining English
language learners from a translingual perspective. ELT Journal, 72(1), 26-37. https://doi.org/10.1093/elt/ccx029
Bonacina-Pugh, F., da Costa Cabral, I., &
Huang, J. (2021). State of the art review on translanguaging in education. Language Teaching, 54(4), 439-471. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0261444821000173
Brooks, E. (2022). Translanguaging and the
shifting sands of language education. ELT
Journal, 76(1), 129–146. https://doi.org/10.1093/elt/ccab062
Bui, G., & Tai, K. W. H. (2022).
Revisiting functional adequacy and task-based language teaching in the
GBA: Insights from translanguaging. Asian-Pacific
Journal of Second and Foreign Language Education, 7(Article 40), 1-14. https://doi.org/10.1186/s40862-022-00160-7
Cenoz, J., & Gorter, D. (2021). Pedagogical translanguaging. Cambridge
University Press. https://doi.org/10.1017/9781009029384.
Dovchin, S., & Wang, M. (2024). The
resistance to translanguaging, spontaneous translanguagers and native speaker
saviorism. Critical Inquiry in Language
Studies, 21(4), 429-446. https://doi.org/10.1080/15427587.2024.2336469
East, M., & Wang, D. (2025). Advancing
the communicative language teaching agenda: What place for translanguaging in
task-based language teaching? The
Language Learning Journal, 53(6), 702-714. https://doi.org/10.1080/09571736.2024.2380278
Hofer, B., & Jessner, U. (2026). Research
agenda: From monolingual to multilingual norms in multilingual classrooms. Language Teaching, 59(3), 343-358. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0261444825000023
Howatt, A. P. R. (1984). A history of English language teaching. Oxford University Press.
Jenks,
C. J., & Lee, J. W. (2020). Native speaker saviorism: A racialized teaching
ideology. Critical Inquiry in Language Studies, 17(3), 186–205. https://doi.org/10.1080/15427587.2019.1664904
Li, W. (2018). Translanguaging as a practical
theory of language. Applied Linguistics,
39(1), 9-30. https://doi.org/10.1093/applin/amx039
Li, W. (2024). Transformative pedagogy for
inclusion and social justice through translanguaging, co-learning, and
transpositioning. Language Teaching, 57(2),
203-214. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0261444823000186
Littlewood, W., & Yu, B. (2011). First
language and target language in the foreign language classroom. Language Teaching, 44(1), 64-77. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0261444809990310
Nagashima, Y., & Lawrence, L. (2022). To
translanguage or not to translanguage: Ideology, practice, and intersectional
identities. Applied Linguistics Review,
13(5), 735-754. https://doi.org/10.1515/applirev-2019-0040
Schissel, J. L., De Korne, H., &
López-Gopar, M. (2021). Grappling with translanguaging for teaching and
assessment in culturally and linguistically diverse contexts: Teacher
perspectives from Oaxaca, Mexico. International
Journal of Bilingual Education and Bilingualism, 24(3), 340-356. https://doi.org/10.1080/13670050.2018.1463965
Shohamy, E. (2011). Assessing multilingual
competencies: Adopting construct valid assessment policies. The Modern Language Journal, 95(3),
418-429. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-4781.2011.01210.x
Tai, K. W. H. (2024). Shaping student
responses into academic expressions: Analysing an English medium instruction
history classroom from a translanguaging perspective. International Journal of Bilingual Education and Bilingualism, 27(4),
550-580. https://doi.org/10.1080/13670050.2023.2232089
Tai, K. W. H., & Li, W. (2025). Engaging
students in learning and creating different translanguaging sub-spaces in Hong
Kong English Medium Instruction history classrooms. Language and Education, 39(1), 190-231. https://doi.org/10.1080/09500782.2023.2248958
Author
bio
Martin East is Professor of Language Education in the
School of Education and Social Practice, the University of Auckland, New
Zealand. He has published widely in the fields of language pedagogy and
language assessment. His works have often investigated innovative practices and
their implications for teaching and learning. Recently, and in collaboration
with his colleague Danping Wang, he has explored the implications of
translanguaging for the theory and practice of task-based language teaching.
Their most recent work together will soon be available as Gold Open Access in
the Cambridge Elements Applied Linguistics series: East and Wang - Exploring the Intersection
between Task-based Language Teaching and Translanguaging (https://vimeo.com/1230865782).
Email: m.east@auckland.ac.nz
ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0003-3681-5028