Brief Reports in Language Research
Brief Reports in Language
Research, 1, 260103 (2026)
https://doi.org/10.65553/BRLR.260103
Genuine vs.
Virtual Social Presence in AI-Assisted Task-Based Interaction: An Exploratory
Study on Willingness to Communicate and L2 Performance Across Task Complexity
Gavin Bui*
Department of English, The Hang Seng University of Hong
Kong, China
Abstract
This
empirical brief report investigates how genuine (human-to-human) and virtual (human-to-AI) social presence interact with
task complexity to influence second language (L2) learners' Willingness to
Communicate (WTC) and oral task performance. Eighteen Hong Kong
Cantonese-speaking university learners of English completed simple
(three-element with low reasoning demand) and complex (six-element with high
reasoning demand) communicative direction-giving tasks under one of two
conditions: interacting either with an AI chatbot (virtual social presence) or
with a peer (genuine social presence). Quantitative analyses examined
situational WTC and Complexity, Accuracy, and Fluency (CAF) measures,
complemented by post-task semi-structured interviews. Descriptive statistics
revealed that virtual social presence elicited higher self-reported WTC, a
trend interviewee attributed to reduced face
threat and lower communicative anxiety. Conversely, genuine social presence was associated
with greater syntactic complexity, possibly through peer feedback and
interactional modifications, with a tendency towards mid-clause pausing. These
findings tentatively suggest that the differential affordances of artificial
and human interlocutors: conversational AI may offer a low-anxiety context that
supports communicative willingness, whereas human interaction may be more
conducive to syntactic elaboration.
Keywords: Task-based language
teaching, Willingness to communicate, Artificial intelligence, Social presence, Task complexity
A central tenet of
Task-Based Language Teaching (TBLT) is that second language (L2) acquisition is
optimised when learners engage in meaningful, goal-oriented interaction
requiring the communicative exchange of information (Bui, 2026a; Ellis, 2003; Long, 2015). For interaction to foster
acquisition, however, learners must first be willing to take communicative
risks. In second language acquisition (SLA), this disposition is conceptualised
as Willingness to Communicate (WTC),
defined by MacIntyre
et al. (1998) as a learner's readiness to enter
into discourse at a specific moment with a specific interlocutor. While
WTC was originally treated as an enduring personality trait, contemporary
research recognises it as a dynamic, situationally contingent construct that
fluctuates according to affective states, cognitive demands, and social
contextual variables (Aubrey & Yashima, 2023; Bui, 2026c; Cao, 2011; Peng, 2025).
The rapid advent of
conversational Artificial Intelligence (AI) and large language model chatbots
provides L2 pedagogy with accessible, on-demand speaking partners. Fathi et al. (2024) reported that EFL
learners interacting with an AI chatbot outperformed a face-to-face group on
speaking skills and WTC, whereas Bui (2026b) showed that learners' initial enthusiasm for AI
interlocutors cooled over seven weeks as limitations in social presence,
prosody, and interactional authenticity became salient. Wang (2026) similarly found that
multimodal generative AI supported task preparation and lowered affective
barriers but yielded limited gains in fluency and delivery confidence, with
learners continuing to rely on human interlocutors for validation. However,
these studies either compared AI with conventional instruction rather than
isolating interlocutor presence within a controlled task-based design (Fathi et al., 2024), or did not
systematically manipulate task complexity (Bui, 2026b; Wang, 2026); no study has experimentally
crossed interlocutor type (genuine vs. virtual social presence) with task
complexity to examine their joint effects on situational WTC and CAF measures.
To understand the
differentiated affordances derived from human and AI as interlocutors in
language teaching and learning, it is helpful to explore the notion of social
presence. Social presence in early
literature refers to the degree to which an interlocutor is perceived as
salient and "real" within an interaction, together with the resulting
sense of affective connection and interpersonal relationship that such
perceived presence affords (Short et al., 1976). More recently, Garrison et al. (2000) define it as the
ability of participants in a community of inquiry to project themselves
socially and emotionally as "real" people through the medium of
communication being used, while Gunawardena and Zittle (1997) operationalise the
construct as the degree to which a person is perceived as a "real
person" in mediated communication. To address the above research gaps,
this study distinguishes between two distinct forms of communicative presence:
Genuine Social Presence: Grounded in human-to-human
interaction, characterised by real-time interpersonal dynamics, reciprocal
social accountability, face-concerns, and authentic negotiation of meaning.
Virtual Social Presence: Simulated through
human-to-machine interaction, characterised by perceived accessibility,
conversational patience, and non-judgmental reception, but fundamentally devoid
of authentic human consciousness or genuine communicative consequence.
In East Asian English
as an Additional Language (EAL) environment, such as Hong Kong, genuine social
presence can introduce communicative inhibition. As Wen and Clément (2003) observe, culturally
rooted face-saving concerns and evaluation anxiety frequently restrict
learners' willingness to speak in front of peers and instructors. Interacting
under virtual social presence may theoretically mitigate these affective
barriers via the online disinhibition
effect (Qiu et
al., 2026; Suler,
2004), creating a psychologically secure environment where learners feel
emboldened to produce target-language utterances.
Simultaneously,
task-based research demonstrates that communicative behaviour cannot be
evaluated independently of task design. In Robinson’s (2001, 2007) Cognition Hypothesis
(CH), manipulating task complexity along resource-directing
dimensions (e.g., increasing the number of elements and/or reasoning demands)
channels learners' attention towards linguistic encoding, typically enhancing
accuracy and syntactic complexity at the expense of fluency. Under the CH
framework, social presence may become resource-depleting factor that
potentially lower linguistic complexity and accuracy. In contrast, Skehan’s (1998, 2009) Limited Attentional
Capacity Model posits that complex communicative processing may imposes
attentional trade-offs between forms and meaning. When a complex task is
situated within an anxiety-inducing human-to-human interaction, the compounded
cognitive and interpersonal load may suppress WTC. Then, a patient AI
conversational partner may buffer against these complexity-induced
communicative breakdowns.
To our knowledge, few
empirical studies have systematically isolated the interaction between
interlocutor presence (genuine vs. virtual) and task complexity (simple vs.
complex) within an established task-based paradigm. The present brief report
addresses this gap by investigating four interrelated research questions (RQs):
RQ1: How does social presence type (genuine human vs.
virtual AI social presence) influence L2 learners' situational Willingness to
Communicate?
RQ2: How does task complexity (simple vs. complex
map-based tasks) moderate WTC across the two social presence conditions?
RQ3: What measurable differences emerge in learners' oral
production profiles (Complexity, Accuracy, and Fluency) across social presence and
complexity conditions?
RQ4: How do learners perceive the communicative and
learning affordances of genuine versus virtual social presence in task
performance?
Methods
Research
Design and Context
This study adopted a 2 (social
presence types: between-participant) x 2 (task complexity: within-participant)
mixed-methods design plus interviews. Participants were randomly assigned to
one of the following two social presence groups:
Virtual Social Presence (AI Chatbot Condition): Learners performed
tasks with a conversational AI agent (Doubao), prompted to act as an English-speaking tourist
seeking directions.
Genuine Social Presence (Human Peer Condition): Learners performed
tasks in dyads, where one student assumed the role of the local resident giving
directions and the other acted as an unfamiliar tourist asking for assistance.
In the genuine social presence
condition (human to human interaction), each dyad comprised one learner
assigned the role of local resident/direction-giver
and one assigned the role of unfamiliar tourist. Roles were swapped after the
first task, and task order was counterbalanced across dyads. Only the
direction-giver’s speech was treated as task performance data; tourist
turns, which were minimum
consisting of mainly short confirmation or clarification checks like “I see”
and “ok, thank you”, were retained only as interactional context and were not
included in CAF coding.
Task complexity served as a
within-subjects factor across both groups, manipulated systematically through
the number of spatial elements (landmarks) and degree of reasoning involved in
a map direction-giving task. The order of the simple and complex tasks was
counterbalanced across participants to offset practice and fatigue effects.
Participants
Participants were 18
undergraduate students (10 female, 8 male) recruited from a private university
in Hong Kong. All were native Cantonese speakers with English as an L2. Their
English oral proficiency fell within the B2 band of the Common European Framework
of Reference (CEFR), evidenced by recent institutional IELTS scores ranging
between 5.5 and 6.5 (M=6.0, SD=0.31). Participants had completed a mean of 13.4
years (SD=1.8) of formal English instruction.
Six participants were assigned to
the Virtual Social Presence (AI) condition (n=6), and twelve participants were
assigned to the Genuine Social Presence condition, forming six interactive
dyads (n=12). The 12 human-condition participants were paired into six dyads by
the researcher randomly based on their scheduling availability for ecological
validity (tourists and locals are strangers in reality). The AI-condition
participants completed the tasks individually. Proficiency was balanced across
both conditions, and all participants signed a consent form and, up completion, received an honorarium of
HK$100.
Tasks
and Instruments
Communicative Tasks
Two information-gap map tasks
were developed following established TBLT guidelines (Bui, 2026d; Ellis, 2003; Tavakoli, 2009):
Simple Task (Low Complexity): Required the speaker
to direct the interlocutor across a town map incorporating three sequential
landmarks (library, café, bus stop). The sequential buildings require low
reasoning demand.
Complex Task (High Complexity): Utilised the
identical base map but increased the resource-directing cognitive load by
incorporating six landmarks (library, café, bus stop, post office, shopping
centre, and hospital) along with competing routing pathways. The competing
routing requires high reasoning demand.
In the AI condition, the chatbot
was programmed to respond strictly via voice synthesis using a standardised
tourist scenario prompt, asking clarifying queries only when direct route
milestones were ambiguous. In the human condition, peer tourists held a
complementary map lacking the routes and were instructed to ask clarification
questions freely until they reached the destination. The two map tasks are
presented in Appendices 1 and 2.
Situational WTC Scale
Situational WTC was measured
immediately post-task using a newly developed 12-item task-specific situational
WTC questionnaire (Appendix 3), informed by the MacIntyre et al. (1998) conceptualisation of
WTC and by prior WTC measurement (e.g., MacIntyre et al., 2001), rated on a 5-point
Likert scale (
,
). The instrument
measured willingness to initiate and sustain communication specifically during
the experimental task conditions (Cronbach’s
). A sample item on
Willingness to Sustain Communication is “I was willing to keep talking and
elaborate with descriptive details when guiding the partner."
Post-Task
Semi-Structured Interviews
Individual 15–20 minutes
semi-structured interviews were conducted in English immediately after task
performance to examine participants’ subjective cognitive and affective
experiences, perceptions of communicative pressure, and comparative views on
interacting with human versus artificial agents.
Data
Coding and Analysis
Audio recordings of task
performance were transcribed verbatim and segmented into AS-units (Analysis of
Speech units) following Foster et al. (2000). Standardised Complexity, Accuracy, and Fluency (CAF,
Bui
& Skehan, 2018) measures were computed:
Syntactic Complexity: Measured by the subordination
ratio (subordinate clauses divided by total clauses) (Bui, 2014).
Linguistic Accuracy: Measured by the percentage of
error-free clauses relative to total clauses (Skehan, et al., 2024).
Fluency: Operationalised through Speed (speech rate in
syllables per minute), and breakdown fluency (mid-clause pause frequency per
100 words) (Tavakoli
& Skehan, 2005).
CAF analyses were based on the
direction-giver’s AS-units only; tourist backchannels, clarification questions,
and AI prompts were excluded. Thus, for CAF, n = 6 in the AI condition and n =
6 in the human condition (one direction-giver per dyad). Situational WTC was
analysed at the individual level and therefore included all participants who
completed the scale (AI n = 6; human n = 12), including tourists in the human
dyads.
Given the exploratory nature and
small sample size of this brief report (N=18), null-hypothesis significance
testing (NHST) was deliberately omitted to avoid Type II errors associated with
low statistical power. Instead, in line with methodological recommendations for
small-sample SLA research (Plonsky & Oswald, 2014), we evaluate the strength and
practical significance of the comparative trends using descriptive statistics
paired with Hedges' g effect sizes, which correct for small and unequal sample
sizes (n=6 vs. n=12 in WTC analyses). We interpret Hedges’ g using Plonsky and
Oswald’s (2014) field-specific benchmarks for SLA: |g| ≥ 0.40 as a small
effect, |g| ≥ 0.70 as a medium effect, and |g| ≥ 1.00 as a large effect. In
addition, qualitative interview transcripts underwent thematic analysis (Braun & Clarke, 2006) to identify
recurrent emergent themes, achieving an inter-coder reliability of ICC = 84.72%
across independent evaluators.
Results
Data and analysis
Willingness to
Communicate: Virtual Safety vs. Genuine Interpersonal Pressure
Descriptive analyses revealed
distinct variations in learners' WTC across interlocutor type and task
complexity (Table 1).
Table 1. Descriptive
Statistics for Situational WTC Across Conditions
|
Task Complexity |
Mean WTC (Virtual/AI, n=6) |
Mean WTC (Genuine/Human, n=12) |
Standardized Effect Size (Hedges' g) |
Interpretation |
|
Simple |
4.02 (.58) |
3.58 (.68) |
.644 |
Small-to-Medium |
|
Complex |
3.76 (.71) |
3.26 (.74) |
.652 |
Small-to-Medium |
|
Combined |
3.89 (.62) |
3.42 (.71) |
.655 |
Small-to-Medium |
Note. Standard deviations in ().
Descriptive statistics
tentatively suggest that learners exhibited higher communicative willingness
when interacting with the virtual AI agent (M=3.89) than with a human
peer (M=3.42), representing a solid, small-to-medium standardized effect
size (g = 0.655). The data also seems to reflect an overarching decline in WTC
from simple (M=3.80) to complex tasks (M=3.51).
Descriptively, the decline in WTC
under high cognitive load was slightly larger in the presence of a human peer.
However, this difference was small (g = 0.644 for simple tasks vs. g = 0.652
for complex tasks) and should be interpreted cautiously.
The interviews were consistent
with these trends. In the genuine social presence condition, learners described
concern about interpersonal evaluation and social face:
"With a human
partner, I'm always worried about wasting their time or sounding stupid. That
pressure just isn't there with AI." (Participant 4, Human Condition)
Conversely, participants in the
AI condition described a distinct sense of communicative security afforded by
virtual social presence:
"I felt much more
relaxed talking to the AI. I know it won't judge me if I make mistakes or speak
slowly." (Participant 2, AI Condition)
Some participants described that
the interlocutor's machine nature de-escalates social judgment, encouraging
uninhibited production, echoing "Online Disinhibition" (Suler, 2004),
such as
"I felt like
there was a shield between me and the AI. Because it's not a real person, I
didn't care about my accent or if my grammar was messy. I just spoke out
whatever came to my mind. It felt like playing a solo computer game where you
don’t have to hide your weaknesses." (Participant 8, AI Condition)
In addition, this participant
added the following comments, showing how why he needed to restrict his output
to save "face," which directly suppresses WTC.
"With my
classmate, there is this silent pressure to perform well. If I struggle to find
the right words on the map, I feel like I'm wasting their time and they might
judge my English level. To protect my face, I preferred to keep my answers as
short as possible to avoid making mistakes." (Participant 14, Human
Condition)
Speaking Performance:
Syntactic Complexity, Accuracy, and Fluency
Performance indices across
Complexity, Accuracy, and Fluency displayed marked contrasts between conditions
(Table 2).
Table 2. L2
Performance Measures (CAF) as a Function of Interlocutor and Task Complexity (n= 6 in
each social presence group)
|
Metric |
Task Complexity |
Mean (SD) [Virtual/AI] |
Mean (SD) [Genuine/Human] |
Hedges’ g |
Interpretation |
|
Syntactic Complexity (Subordination Ratio) |
Simple |
.24 (.08) |
.30 (.10) |
-.612 |
Small-to-Medium |
|
Linguistic Accuracy (Error-Free Clauses %) |
Simple |
68.4 (12.61) |
71.20 (11.79) |
-.212 |
Small-to-negligible |
|
Speech Rate (Syllables / Min) |
Simple |
118.6 (18.42) |
112.41 (16.77) |
.325 |
Small-to-negligible |
|
Breakdown Fluency (Mid-Clause Pauses / 100w) |
Simple |
8.2 (3.40) |
9.8 (3.80) |
-.410 |
Small |
Syntactic Complexity
Descriptive data tentatively
point to an association between human interaction (genuine social presence) and
higher structural subordination (M = 0.34) compared to AI interaction (M
= 0.26) with virtual social presence. In the simple task, learners interacting
with human peers produced higher subordination ratios (M = 0.30) than
those interacting with the AI agent (M = 0.24), reflecting a
small-to-medium standardized effect size (g = -0.612). Under the complex task,
this gap widened (M = 0.38, for human vs. M = 0.28 for AI), yielding a
medium effect size (g = -0.767). Across both conditions, the complex task
elicited greater structural embedding (M = 0.33) than the simple task (M
= 0.27), with cognitive task complexity appearing to amplify the syntactic
stretching prompted by genuine human interlocutors.
Linguistic Accuracy
Accuracy dropped from an overall
mean of 69.8% error-free clauses in the simple task to 63.9% in the complex
task, reflecting the expected trade-off under increased cognitive processing
load. Across interlocutor conditions, performance was largely comparable. In
the simple task, learners in the human condition achieved slightly higher
accuracy (M = 71.20%) than those in the AI condition (M =
68.40%), representing a small-to-negligible effect size (g = -0.212). A
parallel pattern emerged in the complex task (M = 65.80% for human vs. M
= 62.10% for AI; g = -0.247, small-to-negligible). These effect sizes indicate
that interlocutor type had a minimal influence on syntactic accuracy relative
to the cognitive demands of the task itself.
Temporal Fluency
Temporal fluency displayed
contrasting patterns across speed and breakdown measures. Under simple task
conditions, learners speaking to the AI interlocutor achieved a faster speech
rate (M = 118.60 syllables/min) than those interacting with a human peer
(M = 112.41 syllables/min), yielding a small-to-negligible effect
favouring the AI condition (g = 0.325). Under complex conditions, this
difference narrowed substantially, with speech rates converging (M =
108.20 for AI vs. M = 106.82 for human) and the effect size diminishing
to negligible (g = 0.063).
Conversely, breakdown fluency,
measured by mid-clause pauses per 100 words, indicated greater online
formulation difficulty during genuine human interaction. In the simple task,
learners speaking with human peers produced more mid-clause pauses (M = 9.80)
than those with the AI agent (M = 8.20), yielding a small effect size (g
= -0.410). In the complex task, mid-clause pausing increased overall (M = 11.50
per 100 words vs. M = 9.00 in simple tasks) and remained elevated in the
human peer condition (M = 12.40 vs. M = 10.60; g = -0.377,
small-to-negligible). This trend tentatively suggests that the interactive
accountability of genuine human communication prompted greater real-time
linguistic hesitation and formulation effort.
Learner Perceptions: The
Trade-off Between Psychological Safety and Communicative Authenticity
Three themes emerged: 1)
Affective climate: the AI was described as a low-evaluation, safe space lacking
interpersonal warmth, whereas human peers evoked fear of negative evaluation
and face-loss but also relational satisfaction when understanding was achieved.
2) Interactional nature: the AI was seen
as patient but scripted and uniform, whereas peers produced clarification
requests and confirmation checks that demanded immediate reformulation. 3) Perceived
learning utility: the AI was seen as a stepping-stone for fluency practice and
confidence, and peers as indispensable for pragmatic and interactive
competence.
While the AI chatbot created an
unhurried, non-threatening environment for speech production, it lacked true subjectivity (Jin & Wang, 2025). As one participant
observed:
"The AI never
gets frustrated if I need to repeat something or take time to think. It just
waits and responds... but the AI's responses felt a bit generic. It would say
'I see' or 'okay', but I wasn't sure if it really understood the directions.
Real communication involves negotiation, checking understanding, and adjusting
your language based on feedback." (Participant 11, Human Condition)
Another participant highlighted
the missing interpersonal satisfaction in virtual presence:
"When I
successfully explained the directions and my partner understood, there was a
real sense of achievement. The AI always understands, so that satisfaction
isn't really there." (Participant 6, Human Condition)
Discussion and conclusion
Interpretation of the
findings
Taken together, these empirical
findings suggest how genuine and virtual social presence modulate the balance
of affective, cognitive, and linguistic demands during L2 task performance.
FIGURE 1: Effects of Social Presence (Virtual Vs Genuine) on WTC and L2 Performance
================================================================================
[VIRTUAL SOCIAL PRESENCE] [GENUINE SOCIAL PRESENCE]
(AI Interlocutor) (Human Interlocutor)
│ │
├─► Affective Gain: ├─► Affective Cost:
│
Reduced Face-Threat & │ Heightened Face-Threat &
│
High Situational WTC
│ Communicative Anxiety
│ │
└─► Linguistic Cost: └─► Linguistic Gain:
Lower Syntactic Complexity "Pushed Output"
via
Interactional Negotiation
As shown in Figure 1, the
descriptive results appear to reveal that virtual social presence may serve as
an affective shield. By removing interpersonal appraisal, it lowers the
communicative threshold, fostering higher WTC and, on the simpler task, faster
speech. However, we tentatively suggest
that this safety may come at a linguistic cost: without an interlocutor who
actively demonstrates genuine non-understanding or negotiates meaning, the
learner is not compelled to produce more sophisticated syntactic structures.
Conversely, genuine social
presence may introduce communicative friction. The interpersonal stakes elevate
learner anxiety and lower self-reported WTC, especially when task complexity
compounds cognitive load. Yet, this very friction may
be productive: the interactional contingencies of genuine human dialogue may
push learners to modify their output, leading to more complex linguistic
expression.
The higher WTC with the AI
interlocutor is consistent with the online disinhibition effect (Suler, 2004). As Participant 8
noted, interacting with a simulated interlocutor creates a 'shield' that
de-escalates social threat. This virtual social presence bypasses the
traditional face-saving barriers that typically restrict East Asian L2 learners
in face-to-face communication (Wen & Clément, 2003). When face-threat is
neutralised, learners experience a state of psychological safety that allows
them to initiate speech without fear of evaluation. Conversely, the social
accountability inherent in genuine social presence introduces communicative friction;
as Participant 14 observed, learners may voluntarily restrict their oral output
('keeping answers as short as possible') to protect their social face in front
of human peers. All this echoes Bui (2026b), though face-threat and anxiety were not measured
directly in this study, and therefore this explanation remains interpretive.
WTC declined with task complexity in both conditions; the slightly larger
decline with human peers was not reliable, so the proposal that AI buffers
learners against complexity-induced declines needs
testing with larger samples.
The greater subordination with
human peers is compatible with pushed output (Swain, 1995) and the Interaction Hypothesis
(Long, 2015): a peer who signals
non-understanding may prompt speakers to unpack and elaborate their directions.
However, negotiation of meaning was not coded, and the AI and peers followed
different clarification protocols (see Communicative Tasks subsection), so this
mechanism remains speculative. More theoretically, the differential effects of
social presence on performance highlight how Robinson’s (2001, 2007) Cognition Hypothesis
and Skehan’s (1998, 2009) Limited Attentional
Capacity Model function in a complementary, rather than merely competing,
manner under different social conditions. Under genuine social presence (human
peers), the interactive pressure and need for communicative precision appear to
'push' learners to prioritise structural elaboration, lending support to
Robinson’s Cognition Hypothesis where task demands prompt syntactic complexity.
Conversely, under virtual social presence (AI), the affective shield and
absence of evaluation anxiety allow learners to allocate their limited
attentional resources differently; freed from face-saving concerns, they can
prioritise temporal fluency (faster speech rate) on simpler tasks, supporting
Skehan's trade-off predictions. Social presence thus serves as an affective
modulator that dictates how learners navigate the trade-offs between cognitive
complexity and attentional resource allocation. While the overall effects of
task complexity remained mixed, with higher subordination supporting the
Cognition Hypothesis, but lower accuracy, slower speech, and more mid-clause
pausing fitting Skehan’s trade-off predictions, our findings tentatively
suggest that virtual presence buffers the cognitive load of simple tasks to
support fluency, whereas genuine presence forces syntactic stretching even when
cognitive processing demands are high.
Interviewees portrayed the AI as
patient and non-threatening but generic, offering no real sign of
understanding, whereas human interaction brought accountability and anxiety as
well as a sense of achievement once understanding was reached. Because these
comparative views came from participants who had experienced only one
interlocutor type, they reflect expectations as much as experience.
Pedagogical implications
Rather than viewing AI chatbots
as replacements for human interaction, teachers should incorporate them within
a principled, sequenced TBLT framework, as also argued in Bui (2027):
AI as a
Pre-Task Interactive Rehearsal Space:
AI chatbots can be deployed
during the pre-task phase of a task cycle. Anxious or reticent learners can
complete simple, fluency-oriented versions of a task with a virtual
interlocutor. This initial practice may activate relevant vocabulary and builds
communicative confidence with less social risk.
Task
Progression from Virtual to Genuine Presence:
Pedagogical sequences should
transition learners from virtual to genuine social presence. Once learners
establish baseline fluency and familiarity with task demands via AI
interaction, they can perform more complex task variants with human peers,
where interactional modifications may foster syntactic restructuring.
Fostering
Prompt and Interaction Literacy:
To maximise the linguistic
utility of conversational AI, learners require explicit instruction in
interaction management (Tour & Zadorozhnyy, 2025). Instructing learners to ask
conversational AI to challenge their assumptions, request clarifications, or
demand alternative routes may help simulate aspects of the pushed output
normally provided by human peers.
Limitations and Conclusion
In sum, our exploratory findings
tentatively suggest that interlocutor type and task complexity shaped learners’
WTC and oral performance in different ways. Specifically, the data tentatively
point to an association between the AI interlocutor and higher WTC, whereas the
human peer was associated with greater syntactic complexity; higher task
complexity lowered WTC, accuracy and speech rate and increased mid-clause
pausing in both conditions, while raising subordination. These exploratory
findings suggest that virtual and genuine social presence offer complementary
affordances for task-based speaking.
This exploratory study is limited
by its modest sample size (N=18) and reliance on a single communicative task
type and AI tool (Doubao).
It is further limited by unequal group sizes and symmetrical questioning and
clarification mechanisms between the AI and peer interlocutors, which likely influenced oral production profiles.
Future SLA research should track these variables with a bigger sample size and
investigate how developing AI interactional competencies might prompt
conversational agents to offer more authentic negotiation of meaning
longitudinally. Ultimately, conversational AI may offer a low-anxiety context
for building communicative willingness, whereas human interaction may be more
conducive to syntactic elaboration. Larger, preregistered replications are
needed to test these possibilities.
Braun, V., &
Clarke, V. (2006). Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qualitative Research in Psychology, 3(2), 77–101. https://doi.org/10.1191/1478088706qp063oa
Bui, G. (2026a).
Task-based language teaching. In H. Nesi & P. Milin (Eds.), International
encyclopedia of language and linguistics (3rd ed.) (pp.25-30, Vol. 9). Elsevier. https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-323-95504-1.00434-8
Bui, G. (2026b). From novelty to strategy: The trajectory of learner
perceptions in human and AI-assisted L2 speaking tasks. International
Journal of TESOL Studies, 8(1), 108-127. https://doi.org/10.58304/ijts.260301
Bui, G. (2026c). Effects of task interactivity and willingness to
communicate on speech fluency in second language learning tasks. RELC
Journal. https://doi.org/10.1177/00336882261422018
Bui, G. (2026d).
Task-based language teaching: Principles and common misunderstandings.
Conceptual Foundations in Language Research, 1(1), 260101. https://doi.org/10.65553/CFLR.260101
Bui, H. Y. G. (2014). Task readiness:
Theoretical framework and empirical evidence from topic familiarity, strategic
planning, and proficiency levels. In P. Skehan (Ed.), Processing perspectives on task performance (pp. 63–93). John
Benjamins. https://doi.org/10.1075/tblt.5.03gav
Bui, G., & Skehan, P. (2018).
Complexity, fluency and accuracy. In J. Liontas
(Ed.), The TESOL encyclopedia of English
language teaching (pp.1–8). John
Wiley & Sons, Inc. https://doi.org/10.1002/9781118784235.eelt0046
Cao, Y. (2011).
Investigating situational willingness to communicate within second language
classrooms from an ecological perspective. System,
39(4), 468–479. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.system.2011.10.016
Fathi, J., Rahimi, M.,
& Derakhshan, A. (2024). Improving EFL
Learners’ Speaking Skills and Willingness to Communicate via Artificial
Intelligence-Mediated Interactions. System, 121, Article 103254.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.system.2024.103254
Ellis, R. (2003). Task-based language learning and teaching.
Oxford University Press.
Foster, P., Tonkyn, A., & Wigglesworth, G. (2000). Measuring spoken
language: A unit for all reasons. Applied
Linguistics, 21(3), 354–375. https://doi.org/10.1093/applin/21.3.354
Garrison, D.R., Anderson, T., & Archer, T. (2000). Critical
inquiry in a text-based environment: Computer conferencing in higher education.
The Internet and Higher Education, 2(2-3), 87-105. https://doi.org/10.1016/S1096-7516(00)00016-6
Gunawardena, C. N.,
& Zittle, F. J. (1997). Social presence as a predictor of satisfaction
within a computer‐mediated conferencing environment. American Journal
of Distance Education, 11(3), 8–26. https://doi.org/10.1080/08923649709526970
Jin, H., & Wang,
S. (2025). Why not replace people with machines? Exploring Artificial
Intelligence’s (in)capacity for education as subjectification. Journal of Philosophy of Education,
60(5), 834–851. https://doi.org/10.1093/jopedu/qhaf087
Long, M. H. (2015). Second language acquisition and task-based
language teaching. Wiley-Blackwell.
MacIntyre, P. D.,
Baker, S. C., Clément, R., & Conrod, S. (2001). Willingness to communicate,
social support, and language-learning orientations of immersion students. Studies in Second Language Acquisition,
23(3), 369–388. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0272263101003035
MacIntyre, P. D.,
Clément, R., Dörnyei, Z., & Noels, K. A. (1998). Conceptualizing
willingness to communicate in a L2: A situational model of L2 confidence and
affiliation. The Modern Language Journal,
82(4), 545–562. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-4781.1998.tb05543.x
Peng, J. E. (2025). Willingness to communicate in a second
language. Cambridge University Press. https://doi.org/10.1017/9781009417884
Plonsky, L., &
Oswald, F. L. (2014). How big is “big”? Interpreting effect sizes in L2
research. Language Learning, 64(4), 878–912. https://doi.org/10.1111/lang.12079
Qiu, X., Lo, Y. Y.,
Ge, H., & Bui, G. (2026). Second language learner engagement in
computer-mediated interactive oral tasks. Studies in Second Language
Learning and Teaching, 16(1), 13-41. https://doi.org/10.14746/ssllt.41317
Robinson, P. (2001).
Task complexity, task difficulty, and task production: Exploring interactions
in a componential framework. Applied
Linguistics, 22(1), 27–57. https://doi.org/10.1093/applin/22.1.27
Skehan, P. (1998). A cognitive approach to language learning.
Oxford University Press.
Skehan, P. (2009).
Modelling second language performance: Integrating complexity, accuracy,
fluency, and lexis. Applied
Linguistics, 30(4), 510–532. https://doi.org/10.1093/applin/amp047
Skehan, P., Bui, G.,
Wang, Z., & Shum, S. (2024). Re-examining accuracy measures in second
language task-based spoken performance. Research Methods in Applied
Linguistics, 3(1), 100098. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rmal.2024.100098
Suler, J. (2004).
The online disinhibition effect. CyberPsychology & Behavior, 7(3), 321-326. https://doi.org/10.1089/1094931041291295
Swain, M. (1995).
Three functions of output in second language learning. In G. Cook & B. Seidlhofer (Eds.), Principle
and practice in applied linguistics (pp. 125–144). Oxford University Press.
Tavakoli, P. (2009).
Investigating task difficulty: Learners' and teachers' perceptions. International Journal of Applied Linguistics,
19(1), 1–25. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1473-4192.2009.00216.x
Tavakoli, P., &
Skehan, P. (2005). Strategic planning, task structure, and performance testing.
In R. Ellis (Ed.), Planning and task-based performance in a second language
(pp. 239-273). John Benjamins. https://doi.org/10.1075/lllt.11.15tav
Tour, E., & Zadorozhnyy, A. (2025). Conceptualizing and operationalizing
prompt literacy for English language learners. Journal of Adolescent & Adult Literacy, 69(3), e70020. https://doi.org/10.1002/jaal.70020
Wang, Y. (2026).
Exploring student engagement with multimodal generative AI in task-based
Chinese language learning. Computer Assisted Language Learning. https://doi.org/10.1080/09588221.2026.2645428
Wen, W. P., &
Clément, R. (2003). A Chinese conceptualisation of willingness to communicate
in ESL. Language, Culture and Curriculum,
16(1), 18–38. https://doi.org/10.1080/07908310308666654
Appendices: Experimental Task
Materials
Appendix 1: Simple Task Map
(Low Complexity: 3 Landmark + Low Reasoning Demand)
Appendix 2: Complex Task Map
(High Complexity: 6 Landmarks + High Reasoning Demand)
Appendix
3: Situational Willingness to Communicate (WTC)
Questionnaire
Instructions: Please indicate the extent
to which you agree or disagree with each statement regarding your speaking
experience during this specific direction-giving task. (1 = Strongly Disagree, 2 =
Disagree, 3 = Neutral, 4 = Agree, 5 = Strongly Agree)
|
No. |
Dimension |
Item |
|
1 |
Initiation |
I was willing to start speaking and
give directions as soon as the task commenced. |
|
2 |
Initiation |
I felt ready to take the
conversational lead without waiting for prompting. |
|
3 |
Initiation |
I was eager to introduce the key
street names and landmarks immediately. |
|
4 |
Elaboration |
I was willing to provide additional
descriptive details to make the route clearer. |
|
5 |
Elaboration |
I wanted to keep talking even when
navigating the more complex sections of the map. |
|
6 |
Elaboration |
I tried to use complete and
descriptive sentences rather than minimal, short answers. |
|
7 |
Interactive Repair |
I was willing to rephrase or repeat
my directions whenever my partner seemed uncertain. |
|
8 |
Interactive Repair |
I felt comfortable answering
clarification questions asked by my partner. |
|
9 |
Interactive Repair |
I was eager to actively check whether
my partner had understood each step of the route. |
|
10 |
Affective Readiness |
I felt relaxed and comfortable
communicating in English with my partner during this task. |
|
11 |
Affective Readiness |
I was not concerned about making
grammatical errors or hesitating while speaking. |
|
12 |
General Disposition |
I would gladly volunteer to perform
another similar direction-giving speaking task with this partner. |
Author
bio
Gavin Bui is Associate Professor in the Department of English at the
Hang Seng University of Hong Kong. His main research interest is task-based
language teaching and learning. His recent publications
appeared in System (2026), RELC Journal (2026), Language
Teaching Research (2025), and SSLA (2024).
Email: gavinbui@hsu.edu.hk
ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0002-1567-9074